Last year, we had pretty much your exact scenario. We were even staying at POFQ. Here’s what we did and it worked out reasonably well.
- There are two Wishes Fastpass spots to choose from; the east area in front of the Plaza or the west area in front of Casey’s Corner. We chose the east area in front of the Plaza Ice Cream Parlor/Restaurant.
- After Wishes, we exited the east side of our Fastpass viewing area and headed for the Mainstreet bypass that opens up to the left of the Plaza restaurant. It runs parallel to main street which is teeming with people and spits you out up by Tony’s Town Square restaurant.
- We exited the park through the tunnel on the left side of the train station and made a bee-line for our bus.
In 2014, we tried the other option of staying in the park for an extra ride or two after Wishes. The problem with that option was that nasty clock just keeps on ticking. You’ve spent the time riding the rides. Plus, you still have to exit the park; you still have to walk to the bus (and you may have to wait for a bus depending on your timing) and you still have the 20 minute ride back to the resort. In our experience, we got back to our resort later than we had hoped and it seemed like we were paying for that misstep for the rest of the trip. Anyway, that was our experience.