It depends on if you want a structured trip (being at a couple ADR's each day, every day, at a certain time). Or if you want a more laid-back trip (sleep in if you want, breakfast in lounge, perhaps an ADR for a nice lunch, enjoy the parks and pool, eat hot appetizers in the lounge anytime between 5-7 pm, if still hungry later on you can eat at Espn Club, Beaches & Cream -- those are just a couple options within walking distance that you don't need an ADR).
As far as opinions go, we LOVE the Deluxe dining plan and we also LOVE staying CL (but not at the same time). In your personal situation, I'd book CL and enjoy a more laid-back feeling. The beer/wine selection is fun between 5-7 pm each night and also keep in mind all you need to do is ask a CM if you want a beer during the day for at the pool.