I think it is great that we can all share our experiences to help or vent whichever... other disney vacationers.
I will be taking my family down in Dec 12-26 and staying at CSR.
I have read all the post and I personally think it will be up to me if I like it or not.. If I get a CM that is having a bad day... or one that is having a great day I think it helps make your experience a good on or bad. I think it is all random luck.
I still take all the info so I am better prepared... ie. the restaurant think does not concern me as I can find another place to eat... but we will give it a shot. We have a similar concept here in Toronto call moven in pick. Very popular. If we don't like it we don't go back.
I guess I think back along time ago when my DGF now DW were travelling in Europe. We had a terrible experience in London.. I don't think I would go back personally. However I would not discourage people to go because of my experience maybe a word of caution.
Just my 2 cents...
I am counting down the days!!! wow!