JennyMominRI
<font color=red>Live from Red Sox Nation<br><font
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2005
- Messages
- 12,433
I
I also don't understand why folks are saying that saying "Jesus" in the message might be not inclusive enough and hence offensive, but saying "God" is inclusive and hence not offensive. So by changing "Jesus" to "God" it seems that Muslims and Jews can be included. But what about everybody else? Obviously atheists, agnostics, unitarian universalists, people who are "spiritual" but don't believe in a higher being can't be included if we take "God" literally. I don't know how Buddhists or Hindus or Wiccans or Pagans take the word "God," but from the very sketchy knowledge I have of those religions, the it seems the literal meaning of "God" does not really seem to capture what practitioners of those religions believe in. (For instance, since "God" is singular, how could it possibly capture what a polytheist believes in? To include these views one would have to say "The Diety(ies) love you.")
.
and your absolutely right about that, which is why I think(hope) i said more inclusive?
You could say the *Divine * loves you too, but then people would wonder why Bette Middler was skywriting.
. So by changing "Jesus" to "God" it seems that Muslims and Jews can be included. But what about everybody else? Obviously atheists, agnostics, unitarian universalists, people who are "spiritual" but don't believe in a higher being can't be included if we take "God" literally. I don't know how Buddhists or Hindus or Wiccans or Pagans take the word "God," but from the very sketchy knowledge I have of those religions, the it seems the literal meaning of "God" does not really seem to capture what practitioners of those religions believe in. (For instance, since "God" is singular, how could it possibly capture what a polytheist believes in? To include these views one would have to say "The Diety(ies) love you.")
. He likes to wear t-shirts he know will offend people. Once in awhile there are t-shirts that are actually funny, must mostly he picks them based on their offense level--you know, ones about what he did with your daughter last night, ones about men being the boss of women, anti-religion, etc. Some of them like the woman one he doesn't even believe in, but he wheres for the effect
.
at most of the t-shirts, but sometimes they're just too much--especially for the more sensitive members of the family like my grandmother and aunt. My grandfather died last month and at one point as my grandfather was dying he showed up at the hospital wearing a shirt that not so subtly referred to him being involved in a sex act with "your daughter". My mother saw it and was like, "What is wrong with you?" We weren't sure that my aunt and grandmother would actually have understood what the shirt was saying, but my mom taped a napkin over the message anyway. Sure my brother knows that people with his dirty sense of humor will get a laugh out of his shirt and maybe that'll make their day a little better, but even if that's so, what about all of the people who will be disgusted or offended? In that case I think it's clear that concern about those who will be offended trumps caring about the laughter you might cause for the people who like the shirt.
