other than the room location (we were in Room 24 which is miles from the food court and big pool etc, in fact I never even saw the old man pool at all) - there is nothing specific, I just didn't like the theming of the place - I commented to my husband that it looked like a swamp, and he said 'that's the whole theme, Alligator Bayou is a swamp' and that sort of summed it up for me - I didn't go to Disney to stay in a swamp. The mansions did look lovely though.
French Quarter - I just loved the theming, I thought it was absolutely beautiful. Our room location was superb, we were 2 minutes away from everything. A little further to our car and the bus stop then at AB, but right in the middle of everything. It's one of those intangible things, but everytime we came home it made me smile to think, I am staying here.