IMO, although I'm sure very unpopular, I think a lot of the disappointment with WDW on the Dis boards have to do with too many visits. Many here visit so often that they don't appreciate the entire value of the parks. To someone who's never been, or only goes every few years, all the things "missing" aren't missed, and the things closed are just another reason to come back again in a few years. But when someone goes every year, or twice a year changes, closures, construction seem to be taken much more personally because it's "just not the same" as six months ago, or six months before that, or six months before that. Sometimes there's a such thing as "too much." No one should be sad, annoyed, or angry about trips to Disney.
I agree. I would be disappointed if a favorite ride was closed during a visit, but realistically they could close half of all the rides and attractions and we'd still have plenty to do and still have fun. (I know DHS is basically half closed, but I mean over all 4 parks and 2 water parks.)
I was pregnant last time we went (in May), so I only got to ride a few things (Haunted Mansion, Jungle Cruise, Journey of the Little Mermaid, Living with the Land, Spaceship Earth). We also only saw a show or two (FOTLK) and did a couple non-rode attractions (jungle trek). Instead of our normal time spent running from ride to ride, we spent time doing things we'd previously 'ignored' - new dining experiences, Hoop Dee Doo, touring resorts, going to the resort pool, Typhoon Lagoon, SOTMK,... I still had a great time, even without riding almost all of the normal attractions and despite missing some of the non-ride attractions I'd wanted to see (Flights of Wonder, Philharmagic, Nemo,...). I know some people go and spend all their time at the resorts and have a good time.
As far as value goes, I know WDW is expensive, but I think most vacations and entertainment are. Before we booked WDW for last May, I priced a Beaches resort and the resort alone for 7 days was much more expensive than our combined WDW moderate hotel,
DDP, and park tickets (8 days plus hoppers and water parks & more). The flights would've also been significantly more expensive.
I've read numerous times that DLR is less expensive and a better value than WDW, but I'm finding the opposite. Even putting aside that our flights to DLR are about $150 more per person than they would be to WDW (we're on the East Coast), almost everything else is more, too. We spent approximately $130 a night for Caribbean Beach last May, but I'm not finding any hotels within walking distance to DLR for even close to that (maybe we could find a fleabag for a similar price? But we're ending up spending about $230 a night for a non-Disney-owned hotel and I'm still not thrilled with the quality). If we wanted to stay at a Disney hotel, the cheapest for our travel dates is about $350 a night. We'll also need to either rent a car (plus pay for parking), or pay for taxis to/from the airport, whereas we took DME from MCO.
Entertainment is expensive. My SIL was complaining about the price of Disney tickets, yet she spent $500 on two Lakers tickets (and a game lasts a couple hours versus all-day entertainment at DLR or WDW).
I guess my point is that everything is expensive nowadays, not just Disney; and that I think there is still plenty to keep one entertained at WDW. Obviously, I think it would be awesome if they doubled the number of rides, overhauled future world, added new pavilions to world showcase, brought back parades to DHS and AK, etc, AND didn't raise
ticket prices. But I won't quit going to WDW because that doesn't happen (fortunately, we're in a position to pay their prices).
Maybe I'd see things differently if WDW were my only vacation per year. Then I would look at alternatives. However, I wouldn't want to go to the same place every year and nowhere else, anyway. (My bff goes almost exclusively to Hawaii and I think that's just as silly.) There are so many places to go and things to see in the world, that spending all of one's vacation time and money in one place doesn't make sense to me.