Perhaps "require" is a strong word, but I have been told that making ADRs that far in advance is necessary if you want to ensure certain experiences like BOG meals - is that incorrect? Because I would love for that to NOT be the case!
I think "require" isn't really the correct word, as you say. It is absolutely possible to plan an entire trip, with meal reservations and fast passes, in less time than 180 days. I've done it. I did it last June, as a matter of fact. We didn't even book our trip until 35 days out because it was a last minute decision to go. We ate at BOG and had FP+ for 7DMT.
If you read these boards, you would think the sky is falling, the world is falling apart, Disney is horrible, and no one should go. It's getting ridiculous. In one breath people will complain that there is nothing new, so it isn't worth visiting, and in the next breath they will complain that there is so much new that too many things are happening at once.
All of this uproar over new experiences is based as much on speculation as anything else. with what we know at this point, it won't effect much at all. I can understand that MAYBE MK will feel more crowded on the 7 nights between 7:00-10:00/11:00 if ticket sales for the DAH opportunity go well. But even that is a huge maybe. If the event is limited, and everyone that purchases a DAH ticket enters at 7:00, you are talking about an additional 3,000, 5,000, up to 12,000 people for closing hours. But the entire reason Disney is offering this experience on those nights is because it is already a "low attendance" night that does not include pm EMH. It is just as likely to feel like a regular night in MK. And if you think $150 per person for the DAH events is too much to pay, then just don't pay it. No one is requiring it, and it certainly isn't for everyone. But there will certainly be 3000 people that will gladly pay it. Is it a money grab? Well, I guess, but how is it more of a money grab than the fireworks cruises, or the VIP tours, or the hard party tickets, or a fishing trip, or playing the gold courses? It's not, it's just one more offering.
I see the same thing happening with the early morning experience, whatever it happens to be. They have likely found a way for people to pay for early access to an almost empty park. People are already doing that with reservations at CP, CRT, or BOG. This has been true even with morning EMH. Why does offering another option have to change or alter your plans in any way? You don't know park hours this far ahead anyway. That isn't new.
This forum can work itself up into a frenzy at the drop of a hat. A couple of weeks ago, the world was absolutely coming to an end because there was no Wishes or MSEP scheduled for Spring Break time. Everyone was claiming they were never, ever going to Disney ever again (after their approaching trip) because there is no more Wishes! They have decreased all their offerings! They have no fireworks because of Shanghi! There is a paint chip on Dumbo----I hate this place! The tragedy, the horror!! Sheesh! Well, time has passed, and lo and behold, the fireworks continue, parades will happen, and hours have been extended.
And for those that that say, "Disney has no magic anymore," give me a break. Seriously? If you honestLy believe that, then by all means, spend your vacation elsewhere and have a fabulous time. But why are you wasting your time perusing a Disney forum? It certainly seems that your time would be better spent doing just about anything else.