When you make PS - You MUST tell that that you are requesting the Fantasmic Dinner Package (FDP). Otherwise, they will not book it that way. (They have been releasing the FDP about a month in advance for the past several months)
We went 2 weeks ago tonight! (We were watching Mickey fight off the bad guys 14 days ago Exactly at this time!) We dined at Mama Melroses - and it is probably DW's new favorite restaurant! You could order any entree & it came with Salad, Appetizers & Dessert! It was a great meal. We got there about 45 minutes before showtime & sat about 1/2 way up in the Reserved Section. It was pretty nice.
We also went a few days later & arrived about an hour and half early - no FDP this time. We sat in the front row just off of center! It was great! (Except, if you sit in the first rows, you will be soaked from the water spraying you during the show!)
I think both ways are great - and Fantasmic is a MUST-Do attraction for all ages! If you have kids, it may be better to do the FDP b/c you don't have to be there so early, but otherwise, just get there early & stake your seat!