Poly is our favorite WDW resort. That said, it is hard to compare the two as one is immersed in WDW and the other is not. The Polynesian probably has a slight edge on the theming and beach area. The Polynesian concierge level beats RPR Club level hands down. The Poly rooms are bigger. (I think I would compare the RPR room sizes to about the same or slightly smaller than the YC/BC rooms.) HOWEVER, the RPR is an absolutely beautiful resort with amenities that are at least equal to the Polynesian. It has a beautiful South Pacific theme that is, umm, I guess just a bit different than the Polynesian. They both have the tiki torches around the resort. This past trip a few weeks ago, I found the RPR staff to be more pleasant, helpful, courteous... than the Polynesian and it really hurts me to say that! The RPR has a much better pool, hands, down. Great activities around the pool with Dive-In movies. Great transportation to the parks. Now add on the FOTL perk and there is just no commparison. $ for $, the RPR is also a much better bargain. The only thing I wish the RPR had that the Polynesian has is a fast food court similar to Captain Cooks but Citiwalk is only a short boatride or 10 minute ride away. Go and enjoy!!!