Is a Beagle a good dog for an ADHD boy?

goofy's friends

<font color=limegreen>**POOF**<br><font color=purp
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
2,473
We are really wanting to add a dog to our family. Due to a bad experience, we need to be sure we get the right kind from the start. DS8 has ADHD and needs a very tolerant, yet playful dog. We considered a lab because of their dispositions, but we have a river behind our house and I'm afraid the lab would be in it all the time and might even wander off by going through the water. The only problem with a beagle that I can see is the howl would be annoying. Anyone have experience or advise?? Thanks.
 
They are very, very vocal. They are also big diggers.
 
We have a beagal mix. He is one of the most docile dogs I have ever known. He is very protective and as the pp stated can be vocal. If you get one as a puppy you can train it not to be so vocal but it will at times still howl (it's in the genes). Our beagal is very lovable and very sociable but there are a few people he seems to have an instant dislike for (two neighborhood kids to be specific but I have noticed that he doesnot bother them but rather the other way around)
 

Could you clarify what you mean by tolerant?

Due to a bad experience, we need to be sure we get the right kind from the start.
Was there a bite? If so, what were the circumstances?
 
I can tell you two breeds you many want to stay away from. We have a Border Collie mix and an Austrailian Shepherd mix, and neither of them are very tolerant of anything but a very calm environment. :headache:
 
My favorite breed is the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel. We are currently on our second. I've had 3 other breeds at various times. Cavaliers are very much cuddlers and are very tolerant, calm and obedient. They're a little smaller than a beagle with very slightly longer fur.
 
I don't know a thing about beagles. I do know that if you are worried about a lab wandering off, then you should cross the beagle off your list right away. From what I read here, they catch a scent and are gone.....probably not a match for your son. I would hate to see your son have to take off after the beagle to chase him down.

I think this might be more of a case of matching a dog to your son and not worrying about breed as heavily.

If you really want to be careful with matching up a pet to your son, maybe you could hire a trainer to evaluate your son and help you out. While it sounds a little nutty, it sounds like you want a good match.
 
I have 2 Beagles. Sweetest dogs ever!

Mine do not dig. Mine do sniff out "critters" in the backyard (mostly cats) and do bark. The female makes almost like a clucking sound when she is on a scent. And they do bark as they are on a scent.

Beagles absolutely, positively need a fenced yard. No ifs, ands or buts. Once they are on a scent, they zone everything else out and will honestly walk right into a moving car without realizing it.

Their bark can get annoying. However, we have good neighbors, who actually are glad or not annoyed that the dogs bark carries. Our neighbor across the street has said that she loves the bark because even if the dogs are in the house, she still knows when someone is walking down the road because she can hear their bark.

As for whether or not they are good for a child with ADHD, I have no idea. But they are wonderful family dogs. Kind, compassionate, caring. Mine are the laziest creatures on earth. Love to be snuggled.
 
I've had Beagles my whole life. They are extremely tolerant dogs, especially if you have had one from a puppy on. They really are a great family dog.

None of the beagles we have had has been very vocal. I think that is kind of a myth of the breed. When they do howl it is very loud, but that is pretty rare. Ours really only howled if someone came to the door or if tracking an animal, and then just for a few seconds. Now, our current beagle is a howler, but I think that is just his personality more than anything. None of out others were like that.

We haven't had a single "digger". Again I think that is just a personality trait and not indicitive of the breed.

They all have HATED the water, so I don't think your river would be a problem.

Most Beagles due tend to wander. Those noses get sniffing and off they go. My current beagle is pretty good about staying in the yard, but most of our beagles needed to be leashed or in a contained area at all times.

All our beagles have had two speeds...full out crazy or lazy. There really is no inbetween with them. They are the most friendly, loveable dogs though and are extremely loyal and protective. I don't think you would have problems with getting one for your son.
 
I can tell you two breeds you many want to stay away from. We have a Border Collie mix and an Austrailian Shepherd mix, and neither of them are very tolerant of anything but a very calm environment. :headache:

Really? I have 2 of them, one a corgi/border collie mix and we don't know what our Aussi is mixed with but her mother was a registered Aussi who had a late night visitor!! They are both very tolerant of anything including chaos. My Female Aussi mix is very attached to my DH and honestly could care less about anyone else, but she's very sweet and really docile. The corgi/border collie is a fruit loop who lives for chaos and is usually the cause of it..:rotfl:

I don't know a thing about beagles. I do know that if you are worried about a lab wandering off, then you should cross the beagle off your list right away. From what I read here, they catch a scent and are gone.....probably not a match for your son. I would hate to see your son have to take off after the beagle to chase him down.

.

Agree with this! Beagles are big time wanderers!!
 
I have read before that beagles, while loving, funny, and sweet, don't necessarily like to be rolled on or wrestled with by kids. I'm sure there are some that don't mind, but as a breed overall, I think some of them can't get pretty miffed over it.

The best sort of dog for an active boy that may want to really wrestle around is a lab.
 
Agree with puffkin, especially on the howling myth. I have had several beagles also and have never heard a howl. Our current girl (only 1/2 beagle though), doesn't bark at all.

They are hunters. Say goodbye to any bunnies that kept you company around the yard :laughing:. My childhood beagle was a downright killer of bunnies. Others have just been chasers.

But they are sweet to the core.

You might just consider a beagle mutt. There is no shortage of those out there and they are both sweet and hearty (long-living, tough dogs!)
 
We have had 3 Chesapeake Bay Retrievers and they are the best dog. They look like a chocolate lab with curly hair. That is the best way to describe. I know chessie people will cringe but there is no better way to describe them. They are not a lab by any means. They do love the water but don't tend to wander like labs or a beagle. As a matter of fact the couple of times when our current 2 got out of the fence they paniced. Stayed right by the fence and ran to the garage when we drove up. They are very loving and loyal dogs and will bond with one family. They also tend to latch onto one person in the family. My brown one, Roux, is my velcro dog. Follows me everywhere. The light deadgrass (yeah, the color of dead grass) Ranger, thinks my 19 year old son hung the moon. We have had chessies since before our son was born and he has ADD but not the hyperactivity aspect. He crawled all over the dogs and followed him everywhere in the yard and woods when he was small. Some Chessies who are not bred well may be a little aggressive to others but rarely to a family member. Mine have no aggression at all. They don't have the love everyone personality of a lab though. Their attitude is I have my family so why do I need you. They are very tolerant and if you just give them a tennis ball they will be happy forever.
 
We have had 3 Chesapeake Bay Retrievers and they are the best dog. They look like a chocolate lab with curly hair. That is the best way to describe. I know chessie people will cringe but there is no better way to describe them. They are not a lab by any means. They do love the water but don't tend to wander like labs or a beagle. As a matter of fact the couple of times when our current 2 got out of the fence they paniced. Stayed right by the fence and ran to the garage when we drove up. They are very loving and loyal dogs and will bond with one family. They also tend to latch onto one person in the family. My brown one, Roux, is my velcro dog. Follows me everywhere. The light deadgrass (yeah, the color of dead grass) Ranger, thinks my 19 year old son hung the moon. We have had chessies since before our son was born and he has ADD but not the hyperactivity aspect. He crawled all over the dogs and followed him everywhere in the yard and woods when he was small. Some Chessies who are not bred well may be a little aggressive to others but rarely to a family member. Mine have no aggression at all. They don't have the love everyone personality of a lab though. Their attitude is I have my family so why do I need you. They are very tolerant and if you just give them a tennis ball they will be happy forever.

Lol...that is exactly the personality of my Aussi mix. She is my DH's velcro dog and could care less if the rest of the world dropped off the face of the earth!! :rotfl:
 
My question wasn't answered but here are my thoughts anyway. I gather from your title and the hints in your post that you're concerned about potential problems between the dog and your son. You are smart to be thinking about this.

It's less about the breed of dog than it is about the personality of the dog. With that said, some breeds might be nippier than others, such as herding dogs or toy breeds.

Whatever dog you get, both your son and the dog *have* to be taught mutual respect for eachother. *That involves constant supervision on your part.* Your son should never be rough with the dog, and the dog should never be rough with your son. I can't stress this enough, especially if your son has never had a dog before and doesn't understand the etiquette of interacting with a dog.

Good Owners, Great Dogs is an excellent book for your own library. The same authors also have books specifically about dogs and kids together.

Only you know your exact situation, but you should choose a dog that's fairly hearty if lots of physical touch will take place.

Tug of war type games that pit dog against human should be discouraged - stick with fetch and hide and seek type games.

And lastly, make sure the dog has a space of his own that he can retreat to and be left alone when he wants. He should never feel "cornered" by a child that won't leave him alone.

It behooves every dog owner with children around to learn the "anatomy of a bite" so that common sense can be used and warning signs can be recognized.

If it were me in your situation, I'd want to pick a dog that was perhaps a young adult to see what the basic size and personality/temperament were like. This doesn't mean that problem behavior can't be learned, but it's a good start. You might want to look for a dog that's been raised with (and proven to enjoy) kids already.

Good luck.

http://www.peteducation.com/article.cfm?c=0+1278+1495&aid=628
 
I so agree with Pea-n-me. You need to find the right dog and that dog probably exists in a multitude of breeds. Perhaps getting a dog that isn't a young puppy will allow you to find one with just the right personality for your son.
 
I really think you want a lab or a collie-beagles are awesome-but they do hunt-will run game and on a scent will run for miles if you dont fence them in. None of ours-we had one wheni was growning up and my inlaws are on thier third, have been barkers or howlers-they will 'bay' when on a scent and 'bark treed' when they corner something-but my mothers saluki mix is a much much worse barker than any beagle.
with apologies to a previous poster-i would NEVER have a chessie around an over active child-when my younger son was in the third grade a friend of his was mauled to death by a Chessie that up until that moment had been the greatest family dog ever.
Labs are the schiznit-loving, obedietant, trainable and sweet. Yea the will play in the water but are far less apt than a beagle to beat feet. NEVER heard of one hurting a child except puppies unintentionally play bitting a bit hard. We had 5 of them in a row when i was an older child and young adult and i adored them all.
 
Thanks guys. Do you think an invisible fence would be enough for a beagle--we can't put up a real fence due to the river. A beagle mix might be a good idea--I looked at beagledors too (beagle/lab mix) but I'm still afraid of the swimming aspect. DS is very loving, not mean, but loves to rough-house. By "tolerant" I mean we need a dog that won't get annoyed at him for wanting to play or be scared when DS is loud (like our cat--she hates DS:lmao:)

Bad experience wasn't a bite, but we had a cocker spaniel when the kids were born and didn't research at all. She was a great pet until the kids started crawling, then she growled. Once they were on two feet, she tolerated, but ignored them. Stayed away mainly. And she was HORRIBLE to other dogs--would ferociously attack no matter the size of the other dog. We just want a dog that will love the kids and they will be able to look at as a member of their family.
 
TOTALLY OT -

MichelleWV - what was your previous avatar?

Ive said it a million times, I can't remember names, and the only thing I remember is avatar's....sometimes. Please refresh my memory, it's driving me nuts.

I've had the same one on here since I started - as to not confuse anyone who is like me. :laughing::laughing::laughing:

Sorry .............. back on track.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top