Insulted..Do I have a right???

Hope these make you feel a little less alone in your hurt feelings:

My dad's stepmom had alot of money especially after my grandfather died. Growing up they had nice things, homes, vacations, cars (left an actual "inheritance" to her biological children but none to my dad and his sisters even though most of it was their dad's family money). My mom grew up pretty poor so she was never "good enough" in the step mother's eyes. When I was a kid, my dad's stepmom would visit randomly and one Christmas she brought gifts. Something very nice and expensive for my dad, something very weird and age inappropriate for me and my brother and my mom got a brown paper bag full of stuff from a drawer at her house where she kept things like matchbooks from restaurants and pens from businesses. My mom told us later that that was standard behavior from her. SO BIZZARE!!!!!!!

Every Christmas my MIL and FIL spend $25 on each family member. Not a penny more. So if they see something that they know the recipient would really love and it costs $26.95.......no dice. So needless to say we usually get $25.00 GCs to Walmart. Now they are on fixed income and they have alot of people that they by for so I do not begrudge them. Everybody has a budget and a gift is just that, a gift. But in return they expect a gift card to Wal-Mart for the exact same amount. Every Christmas for years I would try to get creative without spending so much that they would be uncomfortable. She loves to bake and always makes a cake when people visit so the last year that i actually tried to be thoughtful I got her a beautiful crystal cake plate and server. She was visably disapointed as usual and the following year came out and asked me to please get her the Wal Mart gift card!! One year she shocked me and bought me earrings and then proceeded to tell me how she found them on sale for only $3.00. :rolleyes: The same is true for birthdays. They send us all a card with $25.00 and when their birthdays roll around they call my husband and hint around about when will he be mailing their $25.00. When we first got married I was appalled!! I would rather have a nice card and no gift or a family meal than to be trapped in this weird $25.00 exchange program we have going but that is what they do and all of my efforts to change that have been taken as an offence.:confused3

My DH's oldest DD lived with her mom all through high school. Her dad raised her and her sister pretty much on his own after the divorce. Once she got to high school, she was getting in trouble at school and the house was a war zone between her and her sister so she moved in with her mom so she could change schools. But her dad and I still financially supported her. I would say about 90%. (Her mom has never had a problem making her pay her own way from the time she was 14 to this day. Even things as small as a drivethrough trip to McDonalds she was expected to pay for herself.) For DD's birthday and for Christmas every year we buy her (and now days her husband as well) nice gifts and spend quite a bit of money. Yet every Christmas, she buys gifts for everyone except us. She buys something for her mom, her stepdad, her step sister, her friends, her co-workers but nothing for me and nothing for her dad. And you can forget about our birthdays. Sometimes she remembers to get something for her three sisters on this side but not often. And while I don't really care about me, it bothers me that she doesn't get her dad anything. Ever. Not for Christmas, not for his birthday, he gets a card for father's day usually. What's even worse is during Christmas and around mother's day and her mom's birthday and even around father's day she will tell me about all the gifts she has bought for her mom and her stepdad etc. Then she will usually say something along the lines of "I would get Dad something but he doesn't like me to spend money on him." This year for father's day they were at our house and she gave him a card. I stopped at Academy to get him something he had been wanting and hinted that she could get him a GC and she ignored me. When we got to the car, she reitterated the "Dad doesn't like me spending money" and this is after a weekend of taking them out around town and out to eat and outfitting their entire nursury. I never learn but I still think it is SO RUDE!!!!! :mad:
 
Is there any chance that he's losing his mind or his eyesight? Maybe he didn't realize it was a 5. Or maybe he's got you in his mind as someone other than his son's wife. :confused3

Something similar happened in my family a few years ago. My ex mother in law quit sending gifts to my youngest son, even though she showered gifts on the older 2. On Christmas, she wouldn't even talk to my youngest when we called. It turned out she had Alzheimers, and I really don't think she even remembered him because he's a lot younger than the other two. In her mind, she had 2 grandkids, not 3.
 
You can feel insulted but I really don't think its worth the time or energy required. Take the fiver and go and buy yourself some Ben and Jerry's and everything will be all better!
 

I'd of been happy with a card.

Given DH and I have only been married 4 months now, we had a family cookout after we got married in May.

His dad actually came up and introduced himself to me and said "It was a pleasure to meet you."

Uh. You've met me, bud. I wasn't sure what to think. Did DH really bring that many gals aorund??


err.. edited to say..


You have a right to be insulted!
 
I had the same thing happen most of the time with my IL's. Some times it was either forgotten completely or a small amount.

I talked to DH about it.. and it was more of "it's what he chooses to give, he give".

On the other hand, my parents were doing the same thing to DH as well. (No, my IL's hardly met but once)

This is the time to practice--it's the thought that counts.
 
Boy do I know how you feel!! DH and I have been together 30 years (married 25 this Nov.) this past July and I am still treated like the "2nd" wife.I gave up caring about 20 years ago so what ever in my eyes LOL.

What bothers me is Step son and wife will not do anything for our DD's. Last Christmas she showed me all the gifts she got her neices and nephews, her siblings and parents (she showed me the gifts as she was dropping off my Grand daughter because I babysat free of charge 4 days a week for a year while I worked 2 jobs) but at Christmas my children didnt even so much as get a Christmas card.

Was I hurt, You bet I was. Not for me but for my kids
 
I think if you feel insulted, you have a right. My ex mil used to make sure at xmas time my ex and the kids all had a gift. For 15 years the woman never gave me a gift for bdays or xmas. Other than the crime of marrying her no good cheating son, I didn't really ever know what the heck I did to her. I used to come up with fantasies in my head of paying her back. But, every xmas and bday I made sure the kids and her son had a gift to give her.

We have been divorced now for 9 years. I have received a gift at Xmas for 9 years from her. :confused3 For 4 years in a row now I have received a birthday card with $100 in it. :confused3 I guess she does it to get under the new wife's skin. Oh well, I have done some great things with that money and I never once think of giving it back. I earned it.

Kelly
 
Yes, you should be insulted but also, just get used to it. You aren't going to change him now.

My Dh's sister has an interesting MIL. She wants a family compound where everyone will live near her. My SIL just laughs-they live in MN, in-laws in Boston--that is too close sometimes. Every summer they spend 2 weeks on Cape Cod at their "Cape Home". A couple years ago my SIL's family went to France and they were not going to go to the Cape that year. SIL's son told Grandma he was going to miss going to the cape that year so Grandma sent 3 plane tickets for them to go to the cape, there are 4 in their family. My SIL felt like calling the MIL and telling her that it was too bad her son couldn't make it to the cape that year since there were only 3 tickets :lmao: . Her MIL does stuff like that all the time.
 
I didn't say anything to DH, he had problems with his dad in the past and he is trying to repair. I don't want to give him another reason to think what a weirdo he is.

There is your answer. He isn't right in the head. So don't go analyzing it.
Obviously he is insulting to you so if the day comes where he actually is "normal" be surprised.
In other words don't go looking for insults from an insulting person. Let it roll off your back.

I would say something to your DH. When repairing a relationship he has to know who he is dealing with.

:hug:
 
Be glad that he remembers your DD well. When my Dad's parents were alive, they always ignored my Mom when gifts were to be given. "Oh, we forgot to get you one, too," was always GM's answer to the insult. It trickled down to us, too. Every Christmas, we'd be handed $5 and my cousins would be handed envelopes and told to open them at home. They got $100 in their envelopes. They got the sleepovers at Grandma and Grandpa's house. We were told that they had no tolerance for children and that's why they'd never have us for a sleepover. We were the disciplined and behaved children, too.

When GM was dying, she told my mother that she was sorry for everything she'd done over the years. She told her that the reason why was because everyone in the family was jealous of my parents' relationship with one another. They didn't think anyone should be that happy so they tried to bring down that happiness a little bit. Nice, huh? At least my Mom could understand at that point, and she got the best prize anyway in my Dad.
 
My FIL is extremely generous but doesn't send me anything for my birthday. Truthfully, I just think he doesn't know when it is. He's very generous to DH on his birthday and think he just expects DH to spend his birthday cash on me (which he does.) When I see him in person, I can't touch anything when we go shopping because he'll buy it for me. So it's not that he's not a generous person, he just doesn't send me a card or anything.

It doesn't bother me in the least. Compared with my ex's mother, my FIL is a peach and I know he would never purposely hurt my feelings.

So, to the OP, of course you're entitled to be hurt. But is it really going to change your FIL's behavior? I'd personally let it go and be glad that you do not have Jeafl's MIL bringing you gifts instead. ;) If you have not read her annual Christmas gift thread, do a search, the gifts are hilarious.
 
My in laws never gave me a birthday gift and only a small gift for Christmas but then again I am not their child. They did give gifts to our ds. My parents sent me and our ds gifts for each occasion and did send my dh Christmas gifts but on his birthday would usually just call on the phone to wish him a Happy Birthday.

I wouldn't be insulted in the least especially since my birthday was acknowledged which is all anyone should ever expect.
 
DD's IL's are always very, very good about giving her the same amount of money for her birthday (or Christmas) as they do her DH (their only child)..

Although I think any gift should be appreciated, yes - I can see where you would be insulted and hurt.. :(

Happy belated birthday though!! :yay: :yay: :yay:
 
My DH family is like that. DH's mom ( i guess she is my mil, but under no circumstances do i call her anything that has the word MOM in it.... ) gave out presents to everyone. First DS got a digital camera with printer, DD got same thing, her youngest DS (MY DH) got a hillshire farm beef stick..... He felt like such a jerk and I got SALSA... It only expired 2 years prior. She was doing it to be mean and it worked.
 
You are entitled to your feelings.

However, I think that he's not your dad and just sending a card is thoughtful and kind of him. My FIL of 16+ years sends money to DH on his birthday, and both our children on theirs, and I am delighted that remember me each year with a nice card.

I have to agree with this. I know that every family is different, but I don't expect my FIL or MIL to treat me the same as they treat their own son. :confused3 I would be very upset if they sent a gift to their son, but ignored his children. That would offend me. But them remembering my birthday with a card is all that I would "expect" and I wouldn't be terribly offended if they didn't even remember to do that.

However, I am not a part of your family and we all have different perspectives on these things, so I can understand if it seems offensive to you. :hug:
 
:goodvibes I would have been hurt as well - it is not about the money, imo, more about equal respect.
I know your DH is trying to repair the relationship but it is good to not let this come between you two. Talk to him - do not bottle it up. Just be very kind and loving, but frank in how it made you feel. No blame, just the facts.
Good luck!
 
It's almost the other way around for me, IL's give me great stuff (DH and I also live with them which is a huge gift since it is their house). My own mother on the other hand :headache: she is just odd... I got a Little House on the Praire style nightie for my bridal shower... I don't think I have gotten anything for my birthday in quite some time...

My dad is cool though and he always remembers his little princess princess:
 
my paternal grandma was the same way...had lots of money...gave the other grandkids lots of toys and money...but she'd send me $5 and a card...
then...call me Stacy
(my name is Tracy)


I'd be hurt.... and maybe say something to my hubby...but NOT bring it up to him... dont let him know he insulted you...

Oh, this is my biggest pet peeve. I am also named Tracy (no e either!). I cannot stand to be called Stacy! I don't mind the name, just don't like being called it. And Terry-can't stand that either.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom