This is what we do at our elementary school:
First we ask for a $25 per person donation when joining PTSA.
Parents realize just paying that $$ upfront will knock out a fundraiser or two, so we get a really good response.
Our two big money makers are family events that are done every year.
A Fall Carnival in Oct and a Spring Ice Cream Social in April.
We get most everything donated and hold silent auctions along with both of them.
We're also trying a golf tournament and a ladies night out at the local country club this year. Initial response looks pretty good - but you never know for sure how successful something will be until the final totals are in. So I'll reserve judgement on those 2 for now.
We have never had to do a general selling fundraiser at this school.
Now if the kids are involved in extra curriculars all bets are off and the fundraising nonsense is back on.