We just bought into DVC last year at BCVs and had our first trip 'home' last month. We loved BCVs! Now I haven't stayed anywhere else (except HH for a couple nights before we went to BCV), so I can't compare it to other WDW resorts owned by DVC; but we were THRILLED with our stay (and we were in a studio).
DH wasn't quite as excited about joining DVC as I was, but after our trip last month, he said he was VERY glad we decided to become members. My girls asked me if we were 'rich' because only rich people could stay at a place like this (and we are very much NOT rich---I am a stay at home mom and we live on one income, we only bought 150 points because that is all we could afford, but with just 4 of us we can make those points stretch by using studios most of the time).
Anyway, the short walk to Epcot was wonderful! After the fireworks show we strolled back to our room with no feeling of being crowded or rushed. We all fell in love with Beaches and Cream (got to order the Kitchen Sink, even with the 4 of us working on it we still couldn't finish it). Storm Along Bay was a huge hit with the whole family. Actually we like the sandy beach side the best. Walking over to the Boardwalk was a lot of fun (and a very easy stroll). We pool hopped over to BW and tried out the clown slide. I wished we had had time for the character breakfast at Cape May's but just couldn't fit it into our schedule (but isn't that cool to have a character breakfast right there at your resort!).
So all I can say is that we are thrilled. DH wants to try out WL next, and so do I, but we also are all a bit anxious to return to BCV. I am thinking of doing a split trip between the two places (even though I hate the idea of packing up and moving). I figure we could visit Epcot and MGM while at BC and then move over the WL and visit Magic Kingdom and Animal Kingdom from there. That won't be until next year, so we have time to think over the whole move thing. But before staying at BCV we had said our next visit would be to WL only; but after visiting BC we all want to go back again! So we loved it.
Anyway, just thought I would share our experience so you see that not everyone is down on BCV. We thought it was SUPER and after visiting there we knew we had made the right decision to join DVC!
DJ