'I'm ashamed for my country'

  • Thread starter Thread starter charlie,nj
  • Start date Start date
C

charlie,nj

Guest
Oliver Stone: 'I'm ashamed for my country'

SAN SEBASTIAN, Spain (AP) -- Filmmaker Oliver Stone blasted President George W. Bush Thursday, saying he has "set America back 10 years."

Stone added that he is "ashamed for my country" over the war in Iraq and the U.S. policies in response to the attacks of September 11.

"We have destroyed the world in the name of security," Stone told journalists at the San Sebastian International Film Festival prior to a screening of his latest movie, "World Trade Center." The film tells the true story of the survival and rescue of two policemen who were trapped in the rubble of the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, after they went to help people escape.

"From September 12 on, the incident (the attacks) was politicized and it has polarized the entire world," said Stone. "It is a shame because it is a waste of energy to see that the entire world five years later is still convulsed in the grip of 9/11.

"It's a waste of energy away from things that do matter which is poverty, death, disease, the planet itself and fixing things in our own homes rather than fighting wars with others. Mr. Bush has set America back 10 years, maybe more."

The director of blockbusters such as "Platoon," and "JFK" said the U.S. reaction to the attacks was out of proportion.

"If there had been a better sense of preparation, if we had a leadership that was more mature," he said. "We did not fight back in the same way that the British fought the IRA or the Spanish government fought the Basques here. Terrorism is a manageable action. It can be lived with," said Stone.

Stone rejected allegations that U.S. authorities may have known about the attacks in advance and said the real conspiracy came after.

"I think that conspiracy-mongering on 9/11 is a waste of time," he said. "The far greater conspiracy occurred after 9/11 when basically a neo-cabal inside our government hijacked policy and went to war. That was as broad a conspiracy as we can get and it was about 20, 30 people. That's all, they took over and all these books are coming out and they are pointing it out," said Stone.

"This war on Iraq is a disaster. I'm disgraced. I'm ashamed for my country," he said. "I'm also ashamed that America has attacked itself with its constitutional breakdowns. I'm deeply ashamed."

In the United States' favor, Stone posited that it's not responsible for all the world's problems.

"You can't see that the United States is responsible for all the evil in the world because you can see so many dictators and so many bestial acts all over the world now. .... There is something in the human heart, the international human heart, that is evil," said Stone.

"That's the evil that turns its mind and ears on humanity and is able to say 'I can kill a person in the name of God or religion.' This is not a human being, this a fanatic. And I fear that fanaticism is the result of our overreaction to 9/11," said Stone.

cnn piece


.
 
Well, tahnkfully Mr.Stone lives in a country, however "shameful" he may feel it is, where he has the ability to freely voice his opinion without fear of reprisal.

And thankfully, I live in the same country which gives me the right to say "I don't really give a flying...hoot...what Oliver Stone thinks about anything".
 
Good for him. Now he can go join the Dixie Chicks in obscurity. :hippie:
 

Wasn't he one of those brilliant celebrities who said if George W. Bush got re-elected he was moving to Canada? What's his zip code again! As far as I'm concerned, he can move! He's a wacko!!!
 
I don't understand the problem? He is as allowed to voice his opinion as we all are. If the press wants to write it down and publish it, be mad at the press.
 
Well, thankfully Mr.Stone lives in a country, however "shameful" he may feel it is, where he has the ability to freely voice his opinion without fear of reprisal.

He may get some reprisal, because people are free not to patronize the works of an artist if they do not agree with his expressed personal opinions. If that happens however, he has given up the right to whine about it. Once you express your opinion, then you must accept all consequences, good or bad. That was my only thing with the Dixie Chicks. Say what you want, nobody's going to stop you, but don't whine when some of your fans decide that they don't want to give you their money anymore. You took that risk when you spoke out.
 
ckay87 said:
I don't understand the problem? He is as allowed to voice his opinion as we all are. If the press wants to write it down and publish it, be mad at the press.
There is no problem. He said what he said, we said what we said. You called it a problem, so you tell us what it is. :rolleyes:
 
"It's a waste of energy away from things that do matter which is poverty, death, disease, the planet itself and fixing things in our own homes rather than fighting wars with others. Mr. Bush has set America back 10 years, maybe more."


Title: World Trade Center

Dist: Paramount Pictures, United International Pictures

Weekend Gross (Sept 23) : $371,149

Cumulative Gross: $69,748,809

# of Theaters: 607


Does anyone recall how much $$$ was going to be donated to the WTC memorial?
(I hope it is a very big chuck of that $69,748,809)

Did OS receive any money for doing WTC or did he donate it all to fight poverty, death, and disease. I would hate if in fact he profited off of the tragic events of 9/11. ( especially after what he said)


hi Teejay32..

.
 
I honestly don't give a rats behind what Oliver Stone or any other "celebrity" has to say anymore. We're all entitled to our opinions and unfortunately we just have to hear theirs more often because of the press.
 
ILUVMYBRIT said:
I honestly don't give a rats behind what Oliver Stone or any other "celebrity" has to say anymore. We're all entitled to our opinions and unfortunately we just have to hear theirs more often because of the press.

Couldn't have said it better myself :thumbsup2
 
Terrorism is a manageable action. It can be lived with," said Stone.

I'd like to tell him, "War is a manageable action. It can be lived with," and see if he explodes or something.
 
Teejay32 said:
I'd like to tell him, "War is a manageable action. It can be lived with," and see if he explodes or something.

Why don't you just tell him that having one's mother beaten up can be lived with, and see how he feels.

Honestly I don't understand how someone is in the mindset that we should just let the terrorists blow up what they want.
 
Razor Roman said:
Honestly I don't understand how someone is in the mindset that we should just let the terrorists blow up what they want.

I dont believe thats what he is saying. I think he means we shouldnt have all of our freedoms taken away just in case the terrorists decide to try to attack again.
 
Disney Doll said:
Well, tahnkfully Mr.Stone lives in a country, however "shameful" he may feel it is, where he has the ability to freely voice his opinion without fear of reprisal.



yes and he also lives in a country that if you don't agree with your president, it's considered treason, and you can be arrested and do tons of jail time.


*sigh* lucky Canadians.
 
LiLIrishChick63 said:
yes and he also lives in a country that if you don't agree with your president, it's considered treason, and you can be arrested and do tons of jail time.


*sigh* lucky Canadians.

WHAT??????
 
yes and he also lives in a country that if you don't agree with your president, it's considered treason, and you can be arrested and do tons of jail time.

If that were actually true, the prisons would have been full for YEARS. I can remember people really hating President Reagan, and they still do even though the man isn't even alive anymore. People really hated President Carter, and they still do even though he is long out of the White House and building houses. People really hated President Clinton, and they still do, and many of them transfer that hatred to his wife as well. Obviously there are a whole lot of people who hate President Bush, there are even two off Broadway plays about hating him. It's become a cottage industry. It's also boring. It's easy to yell and rant about how much you hate someone, it's far harder to come up with a better plan.
I'd love to see the haters go away, no matter who it is they hate. It isn't helping anyone.
 
Razor Roman said:
Why don't you just tell him that having one's mother beaten up can be lived with, and see how he feels.

Honestly I don't understand how someone is in the mindset that we should just let the terrorists blow up what they want.

I don't either, but this says a lot as well:

"We have destroyed the world in the name of security," Stone told journalists...

He's just nuts.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom