Yes I would! Never stayed at AKL but we've been there to eat at Jikos and we looked around a bit. It's gorgeous. When we first started going to WDW in 1994 we stayed at All Stars, then we went to the moderates, and for the last 4 years we've been staying at Deluxe Resorts (with codes of course, not rack rates). Anyway, why not go for the best if you can swing the $$? But be careful, once you go deluxe, you may not be able to go back to moderates.
PamNC