Keep in mind this is a question that is a matter of preference.
We always have enjoyed Raglan Road. Yes, some of he food can be matched in most local Irish pub's, but the atmosphere and overall beauty of the place keeps us going back. Does your local Irish Pub have Scallop Forest, Heavenly Ham and that wonderful bread pudding? Ours don't. You also won't find a better lineup of beers anywhere down there and I am a beer drinker. The dancer's are just ok in our book as our daughter used to clog and we enjoy watching. The band though makes my day. Love the Irish folk music while drinking a Harp or Boddington's. Great way to spend an evening.
I guess what you may be looking for is what is the best FOOD in Disney Springs.
We haven't been down since the Boathouse, STK or Morrimito's have been added, let alone Homecoming. Looking forward to bellying up to the boathouse bar in about six weeks and getting me one of Gibson's cuts.
We have eaten at PH, RF, Pardisio, Bongo's, Blues, and RR was the best of all of them. If you didn't like it, I would suggest the new places.