ICarly a rip off of hannah montana? I dont think so.. but there are similarities..

[FairlyOddGrlz]

Are you people mad? ICarly does not have a double life lol. Anyway i think that a lot of people think that Carly acts like miley ( i know i think she does too ) sam is like lily ( blonde hair, skaterish clothes ) and freddie is a goofier version of oliver. Post what you think!

 

[Babyjustrun]

The show doesn't seem to sound like HM at all.
It sounds, somehow, even stupider.
Then again, Nick hasn't always had the best ideas for shows these days.

 

[Kats~Meow]

I don't watch Hannah Montana or ICarly so I really don't know.

 

[Babyjustrun]

I don't watch either of them.
I've seen HM, and I just read up on the other stupid show on Wikipedia.

 

[stitch'sbff]

I havn't seen ICarly but I've seen commercails I think in way she does live a double life.

 

[C.J. Sparrow]

Hannah Montana is reasonably cute. iCarly looks very stupid, however.

 

[Damhsa04]

I don't think they're similar. I watched the first two episodes of iCarly and it's okay. I don't watch Nick enough to watch the show. I watch Disney more.

 

[FairlyOddGrlz]

Carly acts like Miley and Sam is a definate remake of Lilly or lily however you spell her name..

 

[GirlWithSpunk]

I dont think its like HM.
It;s ok but Idk yet...

 

[FairlyOddGrlz]

I think the theme song for icarly is a lot better never mind it does not work..

 

[Tinkerrat]

i love icarly !!!!!!!

 

[CastawayJ]

anyone else notice how shows are normaly two girls and a guy?

hanna montana
icarly
thats so raven
etc

 

[MadameLeota]

I like ICarly! Lol...sad that I would admit that!

 

[tigger/winnie/tink]

my sis watches both i don't think there alike from what i've seen

 

[FairlyOddGrlz]

The comedy of hm is amateur. ICarly is aimed at the teen audience anyway. The episode tonight was kind of like an episode of hannah montana called song sung bad when lily sang horrible and then they used a program to make her voice sound a Lot better. Dan schnieder or whatever his name is cant come up with more original ideas? I totally agree with people who think life with derek so totally copied drake and josh i mean even derek has red hair like drake AND plays in a band

 

[RaggedyAnnPrincess]

anyone else notice how shows are normaly two girls and a guy?

hanna montana
icarly
thats so raven
etc

Don't forget Lizzie Mguire ( I really don't think I spelled that right lol )

 

[TwistyMisty]

The show doesn't seem to sound like HM at all.
It sounds, somehow, even stupider.
Then again, Nick hasn't always had the best ideas for shows these days.

i second that

 

[Pirate Me]

They are two different shows. If it was copying another, I'm sure it wouldn't have been aired.

 

[crazytp93]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lTGt_Z9As48&mode=related&search=

and i watched the show with my little sis last nite and its nothing like hannah (no double life)

 

[Disney.Ears]

Nope...Nick would get sued if Disney found any similarities.