fyi - i bought a 2004 vw nbc and have had NOTHING but problems with the roof. they started about a year after i bought it and now i am trying to sell it back to the dealer (for a loss) because it appears to be unfixable.
i really love my nbc, but i have to say, i am wary of buying another one (even a later year) because of all the problems i have had with this one.
one of my friends has a audi convertible (the 4 seater) and it is a beautiful and very well made car. every time i ride in it, i wish i had one.
if i had the money, that is the convertible i would buy, for sure.
another thing to be ware of in the beetle convertivble - the back seat is basically useless for humans (i put luggage back there all the time though since the trunk is so small). if you or your dh are on the tall side (i am 5'10" and have to have the drivers seat almost all the way back) there will be NO leg room for passengers in the back seat. with the front seats all the way back they are almost flush against the back seat. also, with the windstop in no one can sit in the back.