I need a REALLY GOOD photo printer; Advice, please!

Mugg Mann

"Just the facts, ma'am"
Joined
Aug 14, 2005
Messages
2,504
Hi! Community board refugee here looking to pick some brains and get some solid advice.

Here's the scenario;

Our 3rd printer in eight years (HP 8250) recently decided to still work but no longer produce vibrant color prints. (Yes, we've changed cartridges and had the machine do self-maintainence to attempt to unclog the printer heads with no success.) I use the printer strictly for my business, and my usage is maybe 10-20 sheets of paper per day. DW, on the other hand, will print anywhere from 5-20 photos per day (she teaches Pre-k and takes pictures daily of the class in activities) and is very particular about photo quality. If it matters, we use a Canon SD-500 to take the shots.

It's time for a new one, and we're a little tired of buying a new one every two years or so. We've decided that we're willing to spend up to $500 (although we'd love to spend less) for the RIGHT printer if that stops the need to buy a new one every two years for $200 or under. For instance, we used to buy the cheapie $150 gas grill, use it for two years until it rusted out and then just bought another. We finally bought a $500 Weber a decade ago and still love it. The philosophy is by spending more up front we spend less in the long run, and we hope it might be the same way here.

Here's what the RIGHT printer needs to have;

-Outstanding photo quality
-Reasonable speed (especially for my non-photo stuff that will have some color in the printing)
-Durability

Here's what we DON'T need and are not interested in paying for;

-Oversized prints. (99% of all prints will be 4x6. I think we've done 2 or 3
8 x10's in the last five years and never had a need for anything larger)
-No All-In-One Machines. I already have a fax and scanner, and they're fine.

We're not novices at all, so get as technical as you want. DW would prefer to stay with HP, for what it's worth. We've already done a great deal of homework, but I'd be interested in hearing what advice you folks have to offer.

Many, many thanks in advance!
 
I have the HP Photosmart C5180 All-In-One and am very happy with it. All I print are 4x6 and I think they are outstanding when I print them from this printer.

Good Luck.
 
I have had the HP photosmart 7350 for a few years now. It probably isn't even being produced anymore. Although it still prints great I have found that the photos that I print, (and I print on HP photo paper with HP ink) usually fade after just a couple months and after about a year, they are totally useless. For that alone, I hate the printer and would never buy another HP, not to mention the outrageous price for the ink cartridges. The HP ink cartridges run out extremely fast and are a costly $35 for color and $20 for black ink. Now I just upload the photos I want to the Walmart website and have them print them. Until I find a better printer, it is just cheaper to have them print them for me at 12 cents a print or less.

Andy
 
If you print mostly 4X6 prints, I highly recommend the Epson Picturemate. It is a wonderful 4X6 printer. I have had mine for almost two years now, and it still works as good as the first days I bought it.
 

I bought the Canon S800 a few years ago, which at the time, was one of the top photo printers. When pairing this printer with Canon Photo Paper Pro, the results are incredible. Obviously, technology has changed but I gotta think that a newer Canon Photo printer would be a good choice. Another thing with the Canons, they have individual inks, which seems like a good idea.

As for grills....I did the same thing, bought cheap ones every few years until I decided on a Weber...what a grill! Not to turn this into a thread about grills, but for those who dont have a Weber, youre missing out on true grilling!
 
As for grills....I did the same thing, bought cheap ones every few years until I decided on a Weber...what a grill! Not to turn this into a thread about grills, but for those who dont have a Weber, youre missing out on true grilling!

Amen to that!!!

Sorry, don't have any advice on printers. I send them all out.
 
Something else is going on, it's not clogged print heads. Unlike Canon and
Epson, every time you change a cartridge in an HP printer you are changing the print head. The print head is built into the cartridge.

One thing to think about when you are looking for a printer.

Both Canon and Epson you are not replacing the print head every time you replace the cartridge.

When new print heads are needed with these printers you will have to do it two different ways

With an Epson you will have to send it in to have it done.

With a Canon you simply buy a print head from them and put it in youself. Not hard to do at all. Just lift out the old and put in the new.

All manufacturers have come a long ways with inks.

I can't give any recommendations as I haven't kept up with printers. It seems the three majors tend to leap frog each other.
 
Something else is going on, it's not clogged print heads. Unlike Canon and
Epson, every time you change a cartridge in an HP printer you are changing the print head. The print head is built into the cartridge.


You are changing the print head on an Epson when you change a cartridge. I know Canon uses inktanks fo rsome of it's models, but Epson uses cartridges like HP. And cartridges can and do become clogged. I have had a lot of problems with my HP clogging after sitting for just a month unused (back when I did not print daily), I would have to remove the ink cartridge and clean it off with a damp paper towel.

Check out the Epson R800, I have it's big brother the R1800. OR the Epson Ultra High Definition printers.

I have had HP, Epson, Canon and Lexmark. Lexmarks bite, IMO. HP and Canon are ok. I prefer Epson because it does not use thermal technology in it's printers. I did tons of research and am meticulous about my prints. I felt when I got mine the R1800 gave the best results for me (I wanted one to do 12x12 for scrapbooking) Also it sounds like you are using your printer heavily. The volume you are doing 2 years is not a bad lifespan for the under $200 printers. I would check into the expectd use and life of the printers in your research.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top