I occasionally comment but just wanted to see others opinions. Been churning for a long time and I used to have no trouble with decisions to close cards. However, since all the rules have been instituted (lifetime rules for Amex), marriott restrictions, 5/24, etc, I have analysis paralysis around closing cards because of hesitation around not being able to get them again. For example, between P2 and I we have 7 cards that provide a marriott free night certificate. I used those free night certificates for 2 weekend trips a year (football) and loved the value. The football team has now moved to a location where hyatts are the better choice. Part of me thinks I should just close all the cards but 3 (2 ritz carlton and 1 bonvoy business) but then I think "may use those in the post covid world."
Currently debating what to do with an amex gold that is up for renewal. I took a retention offer last year so I won't be eligible for another one until after the AF refund cancellation period. Current options are to: 1) Keep as is & pay the 250 fee 2) upgrade to amex platinum for 25k points and get the 200 airline credit, uber and saks credit for $550 annual fee, 3) downgrade to green card with 150 fee or 4) cancel
I am leaning towards cancelling as I have both the personal and business amex plat currently. Option 2 sounds good with the airline credit, uber and saks credit but I also have to do some fuzzy math to really justify another $550 fee card.
What would ya'll do?
In a similar situation with Amex and the Rose Gold but haven't done too much churning other than one year where I app'd about 9 cards. Last couple of years have been 1-2 per year and back to 1/24.
First the gold. For me it's going this year and I don't cancel easily. I'm just not using it enough because my offers on other cards are better. They did just give me 20,000 points for that sign up for making payments and paying a fee - pay over time. I signed up but never have a need to carry a balance. If I can't manage a few big spends I shouldn't be messing with credit cards, lol. I'm on my 3rd year with this card and used my MR's to buy a riding lawn mower, so I'm not flying to the Maldives, or anywhere for that matter. I also have an old, no fee MR card - I believe that no fee and MR is pretty rare these days. Once I couldn't get a gift card for the airline credit, and I could get offers on my other cards, the remaining value was no longer optimal for me. I'm now riding it out until year's end close to renewal when I will cancel. I, did have an incentive when I called after the first year but nothing last year. So, it's history in November. Will not downgrade or upgrade as no value in that for me.
Marriott cards. I jumped on that in 2018 and got additional cards. I already had a couple. Brought my single person total to 5 (daughter has 6 inc RC card).
Amex gave the phone and restaurant credits that made their 3 worth it to me - Brilliant, Biz and original SPG. (also these credits were better than the gold's credits) They pay their way and I'm mostly passive about them. The Chase cards - I will for now keep the Biz - I can find a use for this 35K cert. I will close the personal very soon and maybe app again next year, if I see a need for another cert. Right now, I have 8 in my account and have to use a few by January 3rd.
So, I'm culling 2 cards out of 6. I should be able to get the Chase Marriott back if needed.
I also have an outlier for this group that I intend to try to churn - BOA's Amtrak card. Got to get on that as I believe my AF is due. They have a no fee card with a bonus that I'll use to up my points and keep them alive.
And, I'll be downgrading my CSP to a Freedom. I do love some UR's to transfer to Hyatt.