Hypersensitivity and school

Belle0101

Nothing to see here.
Joined
Feb 11, 2002
Messages
4,911
I've believed for years that DS8 has hypersensitvity issues with tastes and smell. When I mentioned his symptoms to his 2 previous doctors I got the standard line of "he'll grow out of it". When I first mentioned it to his current doctor she was concerned and asked that I keep track of his likes and dislikes.

At his last appointment we went over those and realized that he does eat things from each good group, bread being his favorite group. She checked his iron level and it was in an acceptable range. Because he is healthy, takes his vitamins, does well in every other aspect of school, makes friends, active in Cub Scouts, etc., I've not pushed for any type of testing or medications. His doctor agrees and certainly if he were to always be sick or exhibit some new symptoms then we'd take further action. For now it's mostly just an inconvenience. Until yesterday.

Every Monday his teacher sends home a newsletter and in it on 11/12 was a paragraph indicating that all children were to buy lunch 11/19. The teacher wanted all the kids to eat "Family Style" in the cafeteria. For whatever reasons, I never saw the newsletter. This past week has been busier than usual and we've had some extended family issues to deal with. I don't know what happened to his newsletter.

So yesterday morning, like I've done everyday, I packed his usual lunch, exactly the same everyday, of a PB&J sandwich on white bread, chocolate pudding, crackers, apple juice and some gummies. He has never eaten a school lunch. It's not that he won't, with his sensory issues he can't.

Lunchtime came and he wasn't allowed to take his lunch to the cafeteria. He also did not have $1.50 to buy lunch. He started crying in line and not until another student stopped a different teacher did anyone ask why he was crying. He told her that he didn't like what was being served. This teacher told him it was in the newsletter ("Family Style") and walked away.

He sat at the table, crying, while the other students ate. Another teacher came by and asked what was wrong and she told him to go ahead and get his lunch. His teacher stopped him and told him he would have to wait to eat until after recess and he should have known because it was in the newsletter.

So my DS8, in second grade, cried all during line-up for lunch, during lunch and at recess and was only allowed to eat the lunch I prepared for him after recess, in the classroom, all alone. I know he cried because his eyes were still puffy and red when he got home and he told me his eyes didn't "stop dripping" until recess was over. He told me once he was allowed to eat he couldn't because he got "unhungry". Well, yeah, who can eat after crying for 30+ minutes?

My sister pointed out to me that when you don't have money for lunch they give you a PB&J and a milk. That's school policy. So I'm a little conflicted there too because he didn't have lunch money. Her quesion to me was how were they paying for his mandatory lunch?

Even more frustrating is that I was in the office at the exact time DS was lining up for lunch. He saw me walk into the building and wanted to come down and tell me what was going on for lunch but his teacher wouldn't let him get out of line.

I was in the office dropping off snacks for the classroom. The teacher wants to serve a snack everyday and the parents have to donate those - boxes of crackers, cookies, etc. I've lost track of how often I've donated snacks. I'd say at least every other week.

I know I need to address the lunch fiasco with the teacher and probably the principal but I'm so frustrated I know that I'll say the wrong thing. What I want to say is "Who are you tell me that I have to pay for a school lunch and my child has to eat it? If I choose to pack my child a lunch I expect he will be allowed to eat it. And, would it have been so hard to let him come to the office?"

I don't know if I'm looking for advice, although any insights you could offer would be appreciated, or if I just really needed to let off some steam - maybe a little of both. I'm just having a hard time reconciling that a student would not be allowed a lunch that was prepared for them.

Yesterday's newletter had a paragraph in it about how she specifically asked that all students buy lunch for the day and how that was disregarded. She was upset that 4 students brought lunch. DS said that the other 3 weren't allowed to have their lunch either but they did eat the school lunch. I would guess that their lunch was charged and the parents will have to pay for it.

I know I've been long winded so thanks for listening. Like I said most of the time his hypersensitivity is just an inconvenience but then something like this happens and I just get frustrated at the lack of compassion. Almost like we're being too lenient and should be forcing him to eat. I won't do that to him.
 
I would be furious! As a teacher, I never force anyone to eat what I decide they should eat. There could be allergies, religious restrictions, etc. I don't even think that would be legal -- and it certainly isn't good to destroy a child's self-esteem by pointing out differences!

It sounds like the teacher had her own agenda and was forcing it on the class. Also, keep track of how often you send snack compared to the number of students in the room. If there are 20-22 students, it should be about once a month. It sounds like a handful of parents are providing for a bunch of kids whose parents don't send snack.

I would definitely talk to the principal and teacher together.
 
Belle,

I am SO sorry that your poor son had to go through that. :sad2: My DS is also 8 with sensitivity issues in addition to ASD. PB&J is his standard. I can't imagine someone telling him that he couldn't eat it, yet alone, telling any student that they couldn't eat lunch until after recess. AND KNOWING full well that he was so upset! That would have sent me over the edge. Even on the rare occasion that the kids eat in the classroom, the teacher makes arrangements for DS to eat his PB&J in another room (with a buddy) since the classrooms are a "peanut free" environment.

Maybe it's just me, but how is it "family style" to treat a child in that manner? Wouldn't the concentration be more on eating together than forcing them to all eat the same thing? Sorry, that doesn't help you. I'm baffled.

I would make arrangements to meet with the teacher and the principal to discuss how this was so distressing to your DS. Not only concerning the circumstances surrounding the situation but the callous manor in which it was handled.

Good luck! I hope all will work out well.
 
Tests should be done on your son since the hypersensitivity could be one symptom of an underlying condition.

You need to talk with the principal and explain that your son is hypersensitive and that he will not eat certain foods. Do not address the financial part too much. The point is that the kid was denied lunch and they should have provided him with a lunch. I do not know if the school board rules or some law was violated but I think something improper happened. You need to find out about free school lunches and be prepared to quote those rules or laws.

Did you actually tell the school of his limitations? There is no way the school staff could know if a kid is hypersensitive or just a cry baby having a hissy fit. If you notified the school then they were responsible for making sure his special needs were met. If they were not notified then they just had to feed the kid. They will say they did not know and would have acted differently.


It is very sad that a child should be treated the way your son was treated. I hope you can get this matter resolved.
 

Are you kidding me? I can't believe a teacher would treat your son like that! Whether or not you read the newsletter, a teacher can't require kids to buy lunch for any reason. My son has Asperger's Syndrome and is extremely picky about his food (he's 12). Whenever there's a special lunch brought in by a parent or prepared by the cafeteria, my son still brings his lunch and eats it along with everyone else. His teachers have always known that he's picky and his sensory issues make it difficult for him to try new foods. I always tell the teachers to offer him a taste and I've told him to be polite about saying "no thank you." If anyone tries to push a new food on him he gets very anxious and his behavior escalates. It's just not worth the battle for anyone. Who cares if a few kids don't eat what everyone else is eating? It's not up to the teacher to decide what the kids eat and she can't require you to pay for a lunch your child can't or won't eat.

I think you should address this issue with the teacher and the principal. Explain it calmly and factually. You might even want to send an e-mail to explain it. That way you're able to stay unemotional and you'll have a paper-trail for back-up (I think that's very important when dealing with a school). In every school where I've worked and/or sent my kids, it's a general rule that the school never withholds food, rest or toileting as a punishment or "lesson." No matter how much a child has disobeyed the rules (and yours didn't), you can't keep a child from eating, resting (for much younger kids) or using the bathroom as a punishment. You can give time-outs, take away toys or other privileges but never food, rest or toileting. This, to me, is criminal behavior!

I just can't imagine making a child sit with no food while everyone else eats, especially when his mom sent him a perfectly good lunch from home. I work with special needs preschoolers and we never withhold food a punishment. If a child chooses not to eat what they brought from home, that's their choice. We don't force them to eat. But we would never keep them away from the table or not let them eat at lunch time.
 
About having to buy lunch - that is illegal, and I would go to the superintendent, not the principal. In our school system, the principal has no control over the lunch program, only the super does.

Definitely talk to the principal about your son's experience! Maybe talk to the teacher first, but definitely talk to the principal!

I'd be furious too! I have a very picky eater (very healthy, but picky) and she has a severe gag reflex - she'll be eating pasta for Thanksgiving, as my mom learned the hard way that you can't force her to eat meat! :rolleyes:
 
That is HORRIBLE how your son was treated!!! No teacher should treat ANY child like that for ANY reason, but especially not just because she wants to be in control of whatever. What a load of crap!!!!

You need to talk with the principal and/or school superintendent about this issue. The teacher was wrong on SO many levels!

As for his eating, some kids are just picky and do grow out of it. Others have medical conditions like Autism or Sensory Processing Disorder (SPD) that cause physical and actual sensitivities to food texture, taste, sight, smell, etc. that cause a person to not be able to eat certain things/many things and you don't grow out of a medical condition. If your son has other sensitivities (other than food-related, I mean), you may wish to get him evaluated. There's no cure for these neurological disorders, but sometimes early intervention can help a child.

I have SPD and when I was a child, one of the schools I went to (private) included school lunch every day for every child, so nobody ever brought a lunch from home. I couldn't eat what was served, though, so my parents worked it out with the school where I would be allowed to bring a lunch from home every day so that I could eat lunch. Yes, I stuck out and kids did notice, but I did get to eat - and I did eat in the lunchroom with all my classmates. (And this took place long before I was diagnosed with SPD, as I wasn't diagnosed until I was already an adult.)
 
My daughter doesn't have a specific sensory issue with food, but she would have cried all the way through that lunch when she was in second grade, too. She was an extremely picky eater and she just couldn't handle being surprised with strange food.

She has expanded her food options over the years, but I would have been furious. If I had noticed the newsletter, I would have sent her to school with a packed lunch and a note that I expected them to allow her to eat it.

It would have been even worse with my son - he's hypoglycemic. Now, he wouldn't have cried. He'd have looked at that "family style" lunch and gone, "Yay!" And stuffed his face, and had a good ol' crash about three hours later - right when I get him home. Sigh... At least when I pack him lunch I know what sugars and carbs are in his diet!

I think this was a terrible idea!

I have to say, I'm surprised at the PB&J, though! :hippie: I've never been in a school building that wasn't nut-free.
 
http://www.wrdw.com/schools/headlines/7281706.html

It is an ongoing issue that every so often makes the news and it is not just disabled kids as seen in the above article. They make kids who have not money or owe money to call someone to pay before entering the line. There have been kids whose parents did not know or forgot to pay then were singled out as a deadbeat and given a poor kid meal which traumatized the kid because the kid was really a normally kid who had never been called poor and made to be different from other kids.

As for PB & J there are a lot of schools that still do offer that as either a poor kid lunch or on the regular menu.
http://www.rockypointschools.org/lunch.html

This one gives for breakfast to nonpayers graham cookies and milk for breakfast and either peanut butter or cheese sandwich for lunch. After 2 regular nonpay meals the kids gets 3 poor kid meals then the rest of the time he has to bring food from home or not eat apparently and will be monitored.
http://209.85.173.104/search?q=cach...es+nonpayment+cheese&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=7&gl=us
 
To the OP-I'm so sorry your son was treated that way!!! His teacher was WAY out of line. I have a daughter with sensory issues and I would be furious if her teacher ever put her through that.

BTW Schmeck, my daughter dined on pasta yesterday, too! ;)
 
I can feel my blood pressure boiling for you.

I see this was posted a while ago so I hope you have gotten resolved by now.

As for hypersensitive to taste or smells, I'm not sure there is a real test for it. I'm gonna go out on a limb here and guess that that will probably mean he might keep a clean house in the future.:thumbsup2 No rotting food in the fridge, no worn undies on the counch, you know what I mean.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top