I went 2 years ago, with the 40% off pin code and I had my 2 "older boys" along. I opted to stay with the pin code, but my boys sure could eat. Luckily we had a car and made many trip into town, so that saved a ton, especially Taco Bell and Pizza's. We used POFQ twice for take out pizza and we used POFQ for their Philly Steak Sandwiches.
If you want to just stay on property and eat at WDW resturants, then I would go with the
free dining. You will come out ahead, because WDW food is very expensive. Cape May Buffet is $32, I think Ohana's is $28. We ate at the Pepper Market thinking it would be cheap, but it is considered a C.S. credit and entree's were $15-so definately use one ofyour C.S. credits over there. I don't know what I was thinking when we went, but everyone can have their choice of what they want to eat.
I think I came out just a little ahead of sticking with my pin code.
But like I said, we ate off property a lot and had many pizza's.
We stayed at PORS for $98 a nite. If we wouldn't of dropped my pin code I think the room would of been $165. My boys did have their own room. This is another reason I stuck with the pin code.