Shoe sizing question: how big is TOO big??
Despite everything online indicating that Altra Experience Flows run TTS, my personal experience is that they run a tad short: in my usual Altra running size (which is a full size up from street shoes, 1/2 size up from daily use of their running shoes), I have about half a thumb’s width at the top, compared to a full thumb’s width in the Escalante 4 and every other shoe I own that fits well. I’ve got almost 100 miles in the pair of Flows with no toe issues, and it flexes at the right spot and arch sits where it should, so no issues with the shorter length - but the width is pinchy enough that I ordered a pair another 1/2 size up (so 1.5 sizes up from street shoes) just to see… and they’re MUCH better! Full thumb’s width from my longest toe and width is much more comfortable. I haven’t run in them yet, so I can’t say for sure, but they seem to be fine so far as flexing where my foot does and I feel no immediate arch issues. No heel slip walking around in a circle.
I’m just worried that in this size so much larger than my usual, will something creep in from being too large with some miles in them? Is there an indication that a shoe is too big I might be missing? Or is this just one of those weird flukes of running shoe sizing that I need to get past mentally and just be happy they feel good?!