I think it matters whether you go to Orlando for just Disney or for other things. Our last 2 trips we saw the airport and Disney (which is like another world in itself)!lol We go for Disney so that made sense when thinking about the benefits of being on site. I have stayed outside of Disney at hotels, rental houses, and another timeshare, but I hate driving in and parking and having to leave at the end of the day. Like all big decisions, look at what you really want the most and then look at the prices to see what you can afford and what you're willing to pass on.