We just tried it out! We're analyzing the cost effectiveness for ourselves, but we're leaning toward "well worth it'. I know that's easy for me to say as we're still in Beta (not paying) but here's the random thoughts so far....
- we don't use coffee filters at home as we have a permanent filter in the coffee maker. So. darn near every time we go to WDW we buy filters. Goes something like this " anybody packed those filters?" "I though you had them, they are laid out in the pantry" " My bag was too full" "OK, we'll buy some, what size do we need" " I dunno, maybe we should get a couple sizes?". ..If I had a dollar for every time we've bought coffee filters in 7 years of ownership, we'd have a lot more dollars and a lot less coffee filters. Ditto on tea bags, aloe vera, swim suits, etc
- we do cook in the room. So every time we go down it's either buy zip loc bags and plastic wrap or waste food.
- numerous things are a fortune if you have to buy them suddenly at the resort or near the resort. These are caused by all the unforseen disasters requiring antibiotic ointment, band aids, feminine products, allergy medicine, etc. There isn't enough luggage to drag down the whole darn medicine chest and there isn't enough time to pack it.
- I own a business as a marketing consultant, DH is an accountant and writer/teacher of taxation. For both of us, our time is worth money. BOTH of us on this trip worked up to the last minute. We both were actually still getting cell phone calls from clients as we left. I even got a call when we changed planes. Often, neither one of us has the time before a vacation to pack a special bag to make the room usable as home. I try and plan for it, but if a good client calls with a problem, they get my attention.
-DH can be pretty cheap, but his line to me is often "what is your time worth?". It's not only the "stuff", it's the hours required to think about the stuff . We often have said it's too much trouble to take a vacation because of all the hotel, air, car rental reservations, packing, pet-sitting plans, food that needs to be frozen and put away so it doesn't go bad while we are gone, someone to take care of the mail and package delivery at home and office.... Just as
DVC has taken away a lot of the uncertainty of accomodations, Owner's Locker seems to take away some more of the planning stress.
- As others have said, there is a limit to the amount of luggage you can carry these days, and for us, one of those pieces has to be a computer. We may or may not plan on working, but we'd better be prepared for an emergency.
- another cost issue: DH has had both hip and knee surgery. There is a pretty tight limit on how much weight he can lift and carry, and how far he can carry it. I have no restrictions, but only have 2 hands and can only juggle so much. So, if you figure extra bags will cost us in the form of skycaps, bell services and valet, there is some savings in having one batch of stuff waiting for us.
Anyway, right now looks like we are on the yes side of the "is it worth it" debate.
By the way, in addition to what others have packed, we threw in a Winn Dixie discount card and a ABC discount card for shopping only in Florida!