How do YOU eat an Oreo cookie?

[mla1977]

I take them apart, eat the half without the cream and move on to the next one and do the same thing. Then I combine to the two halves with the cream and eat them that way. Homemade double stuff. Even better with actual double stuff = homemade quadruple stuff!

 

[belle&sebastiansmom]

I love Oreos, but I eat them in a weird way, I'll admit. It' usually grosses everyone out. But I run my Oreos under the water faucet. Don't know how this started, my mom said I was really young the first time I did this, but it has stayed with me. I love them falling apart gooey. Milk doesn't cut it (and I don't like to drink plain white milk)! I'll eat them this way or practically stale when you can almost bend them in half. Thankfully my kids don't eat their Oreos in such a unique way!

 

[~disneydiva~]

Dunk them in milk...I toss the milk out after. I also like dipping them in cream cheese. I know...I'm weird.

 

[ChrizJen]

suejai, those look absolutely divine!!! Like even better than the original!! I'm going to try them this baking season!

And to the OP, this is how I eat OREOs:
I twist them apart, eat the filling, and set the cookie parts aside. Once I've finished this with all of my cookies, I pour myself a glass of ice cold milk. (I wait until this point so that my milk stays as cold as possible for as long as possible!) Then I dunk and hold the cookies in the milk (I can't tell you that I've actually timed the dunks, it's more of an instinct type thing. You just "know" when the cookie is perfectly dunked.) Then once I've finished dunking and eating, I drink the milk!

 

[All American]

I just eat it. My mother-in-law's Macaw, however....

You show him a bag of Oreos, and his eyes dialate. This is followed by a very loud "MMMMMMMMM. Cook-EE." When you give him the Oreo, he pulls of one end and licks the cream and drops the cookie part when it's gone.

Strangest thing I have ever seen.

 

[Darsa]

I hold mine in a cup of milk until just soggy, then jam it in my mouth After, I drink the milk (skim) to try to stave off the guilt!

 

[::Snow_White::]

I just eat it. Three bites usually, no milk, & no taking it apart.

 

[Liberty Belle]

I don't. I think they're a complete waste of calories. Now I'll gobble a chocolate chip cookie down in two bites!

 

[luvmylittleboy2003]

Dunked in milk then toss the milk out.

 

[MushyMushy]

I only like Double Stuff. I'll take it apart and just eat one cookie with the cream and either toss the other chocolate part or give it to whoever is next to me (usually DH). Once in a while I'll give one to the big dog... I know dogs aren't supposed to have chocolate, but she's a freakin horse and nothing phases her.

 

[N.Bailey]

I just eat it. My mother-in-law's Macaw, however....

You show him a bag of Oreos, and his eyes dialate. This is followed by a very loud "MMMMMMMMM. Cook-EE." When you give him the Oreo, he pulls of one end and licks the cream and drops the cookie part when it's gone.

Strangest thing I have ever seen.

Now this is adorable!

 

[M&N]

I hate this thread for even mentioning those yummy cookies. I cannot control myself around them and so have to not even think of them. My answer would have been 'a box at a time...or until I was sick of them.' I am now pre-diabetic so cannot go near them. I always dunked...never ate the creme out first.

 

[nmmom95]

I prefer Double Stuff and I stick them in my mouth whole-no milk necessary!

 

[Luv2Scrap]

I take them apart, eat the half without the cream and move on to the next one and do the same thing. Then I combine to the two halves with the cream and eat them that way. Homemade double stuff. Even better with actual double stuff = homemade quadruple stuff!

OMG, I gotta go try this right now!

 

[Luv2Scrap]

You guys are NOT going to believe this! I just went to try the quadruple Oreo thing, and guess what - there was only ONE oreo cookie left!

That is just SO wrong!

I wonder who ate them....

 

[kristilew]

I eat my oreos frozen....We keep them in the freezer with the family rule that we only can get them out during hurricanes, once the power has failed. But I always sneak a few when no one is home

 

[arminnie]

I don't think I've eaten one in years - but I always ate the filling and often tossed the cookie part.

Right after I'd moved in with my dad (me 50s and him in his 80s) - I ate the filling and threw away the cookies. He got FURIOUS with me. You'd have thought that I was throwing away dollar bills.

A year or so later I'd bought some sugared almonds (Jordan almonds I think they are called). He liked to eat all of the sugar off and then take the almond out of his mouth (because he didn't have his teeth in). I found this little pile of nude almonds.

I acted like I was eating those almonds (I knew better), and he became unglued! So I got to tell him that throwing away those almonds was at least as bad as me throwing away the cookie part of an almond.

 

[GRUMPY PIRATE]

I eat my oreos frozen....We keep them in the freezer with the family rule that we only can get them out during hurricanes, once the power has failed. But I always sneak a few when no one is home

A hurricane can also be a drink!!!

just mix the drink and shut the power at the fuze box off!!!

 

[kristilew]

A hurricane can also be a drink!!!

just mix the drink and shut the power at the fuze box off!!!

excellent point

 

[mla1977]

You guys are NOT going to believe this! I just went to try the quadruple Oreo thing, and guess what - there was only ONE oreo cookie left!

That is just SO wrong!

I wonder who ate them....

Oh no!

Once I did this at work and smiled and showed the quadruple stuff to my friend before eating it. She said I looked insanely happy showing it to her.