Honest opinions on our ADR's for upcoming trip

[bakemma]

This is our first time on the dining plan and we have the following ADR's for our family of 5, 2 adults, 15 yo and 7 yo twins:

Boma
Mama Melrose Fantasmic
Chef Des France
'Ohana
Le Cellier (lunch time, no dinner ADR available)
1900 Park Fare
Cape May Cafe

Does it look like a good selection over all and will we be getting the "most bang" for our buck at these places? Mama Melrose has quite mixed reviews but we have been there twice before and enjoyed it. We've also been to 1900 Park Fare and this will be our only character experience. Any suggestions?

 

[ntsammy5]

These are all good, but I'm not a big fan of Mamma Melrose - just never appealed to me. We avoind eating at MGM like the plague! Too bad because they used to have a Chinese restaurant there that I liked.

 

[NeverlandClub23]

This is our first time on the dining plan and we have the following ADR's for our family of 5, 2 adults, 15 yo and 7 yo twins:

Boma (didn't like it at all, most love it)
Mama Melrose Fantasmic (liked it)
Chef Des France (my #1 restaurant in WDW)
'Ohana (my#2 restaurant in WDW)
Le Cellier (lunch time, no dinner ADR available) (liked it)
1900 Park Fare (liked it)
Cape May Cafe (never eaten here)

Does it look like a good selection over all and will we be getting the "most bang" for our buck at these places? Mama Melrose has quite mixed reviews but we have been there twice before and enjoyed it. We've also been to 1900 Park Fare and this will be our only character experience. Any suggestions?

I think you made some great choices! To me, 'Ohana's feels like it's worth much more than what it costs to eat there.

 

[tkillini99]

I think your selections look great! Boma and Ohana are two of my favorites, and Le Cellier, Mama Melrose and Cape May are all good as well. We are trying 1900 Park Fare on our upcoming trip, and I would like to try Chefs de France sometime as well! I think you've got a great variety. Have a good trip!

 

[Luuvebugg]

I think those are great choices, and we have many of the same for our upcoming trip. One other one we love,, and make sure we get to each time is Liberty Tree Tavern in MK..I've heard some people don't like it there, but we love it. It is a family style rest, set in colonial times. They recently took the characters away, but we are still looking forward to it.
Have a great trip!

 

[Cat0727]

I think they all look great! I've been to Mama Melrose only once but I really enjoyed it when I was there. I thought their chicken parm was really good. Have a fun trip!