I love answering the question of why do you homeschool when it is asked so nicely!
Our deciding factor came when DD was in kinderg. I started on this road to investigating hsing when the district announced it would be switching to a four day school week the next year. This meant DD would be gone from 7:20 to 4:30 4 days a week at the age of 6. I think not. They didn't end up doing this, but the damage was already done!! I was intrigued by all I had learned. THEN a month or so later, DD went to renew a library book that she hadn't had a chance to finish reading. They wouldn't let her renew it and she got in trouble for checking out a chapter book. Excuse me??? This child had known what book she wanted, gone to the chapter book section, found the author alphabetically and gotten the book. I went to talk to the librarian. No room for movement there. I was told DD wouldn't be allowed to check out books from that area until THIRD grade! (Three years away!) Okaaaayyyy, let's not allow the children to excel or work at their own level or anything.
I also spent a bit of time that year trying to convince her teacher that since DD was in fact, reading chapter books (It was Betsy, Tacy and Tib, by the way.) That perhaps it was not a real great use of her time to be learning the sounds of consonants. No budging there either. In about March, DD said to me as we were driving down the road, "You know mom, I don't understand why I go to kindergarten. I think I already know everything they are going to teach me. What am I supposed to be doing there?" This was said in all innocence and was a major wake up call for me. WHY spend 12 years of your life waiting for other people to catch up? I did that and it wasn't fun. I also spent that 12 years, pretending I wasn't as smart as I was so that other people wouldn't take offense. How dumb is that?
NOW, however, we continue to homeschool for totally different reasons. Among them, I can meet the needs and interests of my children much more easily than someone who has them amidst 30 other children. My kids love learning--in fact my 5 yo just went outside to play and said, "Don't start school without me Mom!" I love learning with my kids and there are so many opportunities for things we can do and places we can go as a family to learn more about history, science, industry, you name it! I can tailor our learning to what our interests are at the time. Last year, my then 4 yo was obsessed with volcanoes so we did every volcano experiment under the sun, we looked at maps of the most active volcanoes and compared the climates in those areas, we learned all about Pompeii and Herculaneum and then DD decided she was really into rocks and we just segued into how rocks are formed, where they come from and what they can tell us. I also love the flexibilty and freedom. We stop schooling in May because it is nice outside and we don't want to do lessons any more and we start again in August because everyone is getting a little cranky and bored by then.
I am sooo thankful that we have the freedom to do this and I also know I am blessed to live in a state that is pretty easy going overall.
We couldn't afford private school either, but at this point, I wouldn't send them anyway!