I'm trying to figure out the whole diploma part of all this. Okay. If I don't do an accredited package program that at the end awards them a regular high school diploma and pick they're different subjects from different companies, where do they get a diploma when they finish high school? One of the things I am absolutely not willing to budge on is the thought of the boys ending up with a GED. That's not acceptable to me. I want them to get a regular diploma. I've spent hours online trying to find the answer to this question. Believe me, I'd love to **not** do a package program.
If it's college you're worried about, the whole diploma thing is much less of an issue than you might think. Our two oldest both got into the college of their choice without a GED or 'real' diploma. In the case of my oldest son, it was into several ivy league schools. Most colleges now are not only accepting of Home-schoolers, but many actively recruit them. It is a common misunderstanding that a high school diploma is a requirement for college admission, it isn't in many cases.
We had a kind of funny episode years ago now when my oldest was trying to get into the local community college to take credit courses-he was 15 at the time. Anyway, we thought we had everything all set until a few days before he was to start when the admissions officer called and said 'all we need is a copy of his diploma...

Anyway, my wife called a good friend and seasoned home-schooler whose advice was 'just make him one!' So we did, she made him a 'diploma' on the computer printed it out, I signed as principle, and we faxed it over and held our breath. The admissions counselor called back the next day and said "great, thanks, that's all we needed". The just needed to check a box off on their list, they didn't really care about the diploma itself at all.
After that he went on to earn a associates degree from the CC, and then transfer in to RIT. Once you have the AS, no one cares about your HS diploma.
I can say for an absolute fact that you do not need a HS diploma to get into any community college in NY or CT, can't swear to the rest. They admit you based on thier placement tests. My daughter just took them last week, and even as a so-so homeschool math student, tested into a fairly high math class (She was NOT pleased by that at all!)
We have found that CC's are an excellent adjunct to homeschooling older teens, Most of the classes are really on a par with AP high school classes (at least as they used to be) and kids can earn college credits fairly early and often for free. Plus there is the added benefit of earning a 2 year degree for little or no money, and then transferring into a 4 year school and only paying 2 years of high tuition. College for 1/2 price! and let me tell you, at a school like RIT, that's a life saver!!!

Once you get a BS or BA, no one cares where you took freshman English.