Hey there. I'll probably hover here a lot. We've Hs for most of my ds(8), schooling.. He "tried" school last year for 2nd, isn't happy about the thought of returning this year. My daughter "tried" K this year, also would like to hs again this year.
The school is good, nothing horrible. But my kids are a bit sad and lonely there. (and bored!) Of course, being the oddballs we are, they weren't exactly happy at home either- they are not joiners, and neither am I, so we found HS to be very lonely and isolating as well.
I'm still torn. I don't like them being isolated at home, but I don't like them being with groups of kids who ostracize them either. Unsure which is worse! So, while we decide, I'll be continuing to read and

act like a homeschooler.
Lisa... this sounds like you're in a tough spot. First, I'd pick being at home over being w/ kids who ostracize each other.
You know, you don't have to be "joiners" to *get out there* into the world of homeschooling. I see you live in NJ... are you close to the city? I live right where NY/NJ/PA meet, and I'm on a few yahoo groups that stretch from where I live to the city. There are so many bulletin board type outings that happen in the city (meaning you're not a "member" of any one community), they just post "hey, we'll be at this museum at this time and day", and you guys would just go, to 'see' other homeschoolers, but again, not joining any one group.
You could also do all this on your own w/ your kids. Just get out there, to your local area (wherever you are). There are always some type of local museums in any small city area, even if they're tiny, they're usually just enough for little ones.
Do you do 'school at home?' That's kinda boring in itself. I see your kids are 2 grades apart, mine are too (girl/boy, 21 months apart). But we do a lot of our 'work' together, and it's certainly not 8 - 3, M - F. We mix it up, and have a lot of fun with it. We are also part of a very cohesive community that takes classes together once a week and has park day, does art fairs, science fairs, yearbook, 2 field trips a month, etc, and we have a full schedule. We're home about 1/2 the week, and out and about 1/2 the week. It's a perfect balance for us.
You have to find
your families balance. You all shouldn't be lonely, even at home. Make things fun for your kids at home. You have each other. Some of our best times are when it's just our family doing something together. Do you have a small zoo anywhere near you? Pick an animal, study together at home (it's habits, what it eats, where it's from, etc), then go to the zoo to see "that" animal. Have your kids sit there, draw the animal if they like drawing, look for any behaviors that you learned about (monkeys grooming each other is always a good one!). Get an ice cream afterwards. Go home and together make a lapbook of monkeys, or do a little report together on them. Homeschooling shouldn't be isolating or lonely. You can still get out there, even if it's just the 3 of you. Even in your own backyard. Look up what birds are in your area, take a blanket and sit there, looking for those birds, or squirrels, chipmunks, bugs, etc. It's just takes a little thinking outside the 'school box' to have fun at home.
I recently discovered teachingwithmovies.com and love the site. It's about $12 a year and provides short lesson plans for movies - regular movies. We love it!
One thing I'm going to do this year (meant to do it last year, but you know how all well-laid plans go)... pick a country every month, and study that country all together sporadically throughout the month. Make a couple of meals together that are popular in that country. Find it on the globe. Draw the outline of the country. Look up on-line some pics of typical clothing, etc. What's the weather like compared to where you live? Find a movie or 2 that has something to do w/ that country. What kind of money do they use? Who are their neighboring countries? Our homeschool group does "around the world night" where each kids does this, but presents it one night for the group. You and your kids can slowly work on a 'presentation' of it all month. We use those big, tri-fold boards (Staples) to put our info on. You can slowly do that all month, then you take a pic of it w/ the kids.
Get a star chart, and go outside at night once a week or so, and see how the stars are moving in the sky.
Go to the mall, and do a 'people study'... keep track of how many people are wearing sandles vs sneakers/shoes. Do a chart on it together when you get home (math). Make these subjects fun and a family affair, and you shouldn't feel so "lonely" at home. Again, you have each other.
If the kids are missing 'friends', you have to work on that for their sake. Join maybe one class a week (gymnastics, karate, a book club, anything). Try, try again until you find something that clicks for each of them.
Hope I've given you even the tiniest bit of help.
