I absolutely hated H&V for dinner. The buffet was just sub-par all the way around: the lettuce was wilty and salad fixin's weren't fresh, the vegetables tasted like lunchroom cafeteria food, and the meats were fatty. The best item I had on the buffet were chicken nuggets, which weren't really good, but the only thing I found to be palletable. Our server was okay - not great, but not terrible. The atmosphere didn't really appeal to me either - it is art deco, but overly so....and there just seemed to be a funny smell to the place.
I was really shocked, because other than H&V every single meal we had at Disney was terrific....but not this one. You will get lots of varying opinions....and I know lots of people really like H&V, but I promised myself that I would let others know the truth about how much we really didn't like it, so maybe they wouldn't make the same mistake.
As for Fantasmic, other posters may throw rocks at me for saying this, but it was ... uh... good...but not great. I personally enjoyed Illuminations at Epcot and Wishes at Magic Kingdom much, much more. Here is my 12-yr-old son's description of Fantasmic: "It was basically 30 minutes worth of cartoons projected onto a spray of water...and the cartoons didn't even make sense! I did like when the characters came around the lake on the boat, and when the dragon breathed fire, but I wouldn't sit there for an hour waiting on that show again." Yep, I have to agree with him on that one.
Instead of doing the Fantasmic dinner package for our upcoming trip, we've decided to try a completely different experience: on our DHS day, we have a dining reservation at the Flying Fish at Boardwalk. We plan to catch the American Idol finale show at DHS, then walk over to the Boardwalk for dinner.
Hey...different strokes for different folks, right?