Thank you all for your responses and opinions. Even though my misuse of the term "use year" seems to indicate to some that we have not researched this, that is not accurate. This is not a spur of the moment decision. While we don't have more money than we know what to do we are comfortable with no debt. We have done the research into purchasing direct and resale. We are making a decision based on our research and what we feel comfortable with.
I do appreciate all the feedback.
I am certainly not trying to tell you what to do--it's your money. I would only ask this: how many points are you looking to buy? Because unless you are buying a relatively large number, most of those direct purchase alternate options are very high points cost. If you only are buying a small contract, say 150ish points, you will need to bank, borrow, etc...for even just a 4 night cruise.
I will say this, whatever path you choose (direct or resale) do not buy
DVC for the alternatives. I've done cost evaluations out the wazoo and the deal simply isn't there. Buy DVC to go to WDW. This is the reason why people who have owned for years are so vociferous about buying resale, b/c they know the real value.
I'll give you one more perspective, and again, please just take this as anecdotal. We bought BCV last year. We almost bought direct, 200 points at $115. We ended up buying resale for $80 and saved exactly $7,000. We put aside that money, and it's going to basically cover the next 6+ years of dues!
Again, just understand that the people who are telling you to buy resale are doing so not because they think it's the fiscally prudent thing to do, it's b/c they
know it's the fiscally prudent thing to do. I came to these boards just over a year ago defending our direct purchase, and was eventually swayed. I am so happy I was. People are just looking out for your best interests money-wise, so take it for what it's worth.
Good luck, whatever path you choose you will find yourself having lots of fun with DVC for years to come.