I'll let ya know after we come home next week

Let's see it depends what you're after...in april/may you'll have flower and garden, crowd levels will depend on when you go...i know Easter is later in april this next year and then you've got memorial day end of May. But somewhere in between would prob be fine. Temp wise, earliest in April (missing spring break) that you can go will prob be best, should be warm but humidity not so bad.
October: you've got food and wine. Last October was crazy crowded according to the boards here and crowd calendar sites. More crowded then normal, so no clue if that's a trend or a one time thing. We actually had a mini trip starting Nov 1, crowds seemed to be tapering off then, didn't think it was too bad (except MK). Weather should be about the same temp wise, but humidity is higher in the fall. We've also had a trip beg of October this and last years (beg of nov) were very, very hot and humid.
Oh, price wise for rooms...very comparable.
I would prob lean toward spring if I could make it work. DH and i had gone specifically for F&W this past fall, we were underwhelmed. I think a lot of it was the heat, it was just hard to want to walk around and eat when it was 90 deg with 100% humidity. So we are excited to try F&G next week!!! We'll have our kids this time, but I think they'll like the topiaries and the play places.
At the end, do what appeals to you and your family...you can't go wrong, it's Disney!!
