Saylan
Frosty Princess
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2010
- Messages
- 707
Welcome Saylan!
Regarding the shoes, did they put you on a treadmill and watch and record you running? Without that, they are REALLY only guessing. If they DID, go back and explain to them what the issues are.
However, I might not be so quick to blame it on the shoes. What part of your knee hurts though? It almost sounds like it could be a classic case of too much too soon and irritation of the IT band, which has nothing at all to do with the shoes and everything to do with too much too soon. I speak from experience there - I pushed to do a 10K (nowhere near a marathon - marathons are 26.2 miles; a 10K is, well, a 10K) with 2 weeks' notice to try and get into a timed corral. I succeeded, but I put myself out of commission in doing too much too soon. My training plan said unequivocally THREE DAYS OFF with an injury. FULL days - meaning it hurt on Sunday, so I had to take Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday off, then try a little on Thursday and see how it felt. Luckily some friends had linked me up with some yoga stretches and I was able to start back.
Make sure your physio knows that you're still running, and that they are ok with that. And above all, do NOT increase your mileage/time more than 10% each week. Any more than that and you're really asking for an injury.
~beth
They had me do squats and walk without shoes on, then had me test a few of a group they selected based on what my feet were doing.
I have been rolling my IT band out every run (and at physio) as well as after most leg workouts. Partly it's due to my pronation (which happens in one foot) and so my body has been compensating for years. I'm having to learn to re-engage my glute and to do that has been horrible (my therapist has to break down the muscle and start it up again and it hurts so much!!!!). I'm learning how to walk properly which is why I took a week off a couple weeks ago, but it's not easy.
My therapist said I can run, but only 1-2 times a week and short runs. He gave me the green light to run a ittle more last week as long as any knee pain I have doesn't increase with the duration of running.
The reason I think the shoes need to go is that the right foot (the one that pronates) it feels like there's no arch support at all so I find it really hard to avoid pronating. I do everything I can but it's like landing on air and slowly my foot moves inward and up the inner side of the shoe causing awkwardness in my gait. That's what it feels like is happening, anyways. It doesn't happen on the left, so I dunno.
I did the Whitby Waterfront 10K last year and I think it was close to 10C outside. It was warm enough that I went in shorts and a long sleeved shirt. Unheard of for November right? It's a well organized race and the lunch they give you afterward is yummy!
If you wanted to wait for a bit to try a 10K or wanted to run a second race, there's one in Toronto in December. I think it's called the Tannebaum something or other. Some of the Resolution Runs (Running Room) in London and Sarnia also have 10K running options. I think with the races, you'll want to make sure that they're chip timed. That way you'll be able to submit something to Disney. Make sure you get some outdoor mileage before the Princess. The TM and outdoors aren't the same!
As for the running stores, I get a different opinion depending on who's assessing my running. I've been told that I need stability shoes by one person and motion control shoes by another. I've also talked to people who have told me that they don't believe in all the different types of support shoes and to go with whatever feels comfortable. Show your shoes to your physio and see what they have to say about it. Also most stores will let you take the shoes home and run on the TM to try them out.
I think I'd prefer to run one sooner rather later as it's only going to get colder with a higher chance of snow.
I checked Running Room and found the Whitby one first. I'll probably look at others but I'd mostly be running it for trying to have a pace to submit so thanks for the tip on the chips. I should probably make sure I have the right shoes first since I can't return them if I run outside in them (except at time of purchase and with permission of the stores).
I showed them to the therapist and he barely looked at them. I re-emphasized last time that I really felt nothing in the way of support so tomorrow he's agreed to look at me on a treadmill to see how I'm landing on them. I need support for sure, and he said the ones I have are ok, not the highest support I can get but ok. Doesn't really give me a lot of comfort...
Thanks for all the welcomes!
Margie: I already volunteered for the W.I.S.H. Turkey Trot at 10K so I'm game for the Team one too! I'm trying to nudge my b/f off the couch to do 5K with me.

Birthday-wise: Sept. 5 (just turned 25

Nkkilala: Thanks! Yeah, I'm trying to get back on track for my training but have to make sure I space things out more. I hope you're feeling less sore (and much better) soon!