Pretty sure the Edge doesn't have a third row seat, unlike the others. And, it doesn't get a very good rating in Consumer Reports. So if you still need the seating capacity of a minivan, one of the others might be a better choice. We test drove all four of these in the past month or so, my fav. is the Enclave, just for styling reasons though. My DH likes the Acura MDX the best - another one in the same category of those you listed.