DaisyLynn
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Mar 27, 2006
- Messages
- 1,432
I agree with you to a point. However I think that a well-written book can tell you more than some word of mouth stories.I don't get picking random celebrities and people in history to be your role models. Your role models should be people like your family etc. For example- almost everyone has family that came through Ellis Island. Most did not even speak English. Yet- they worked hard and made good lives for their families. Look how far we have come from that. What about your own Mom? Or Grandma, or Aunt, or Cousin etc. These are the people in my opinion who should be a young girl's role models. Not some person they read a book about. Your own family should be inspiring you to become all you dream of. YMMV.
I don't get picking random celebrities and people in history to be your role models. Your role models should be people like your family etc. For example- almost everyone has family that came through Ellis Island. Most did not even speak English. Yet- they worked hard and made good lives for their families. Look how far we have come from that. What about your own Mom? Or Grandma, or Aunt, or Cousin etc. These are the people in my opinion who should be a young girl's role models. Not some person they read a book about. Your own family should be inspiring you to become all you dream of. YMMV.
I don't get picking random celebrities and people in history to be your role models. Your role models should be people like your family etc. For example- almost everyone has family that came through Ellis Island. Most did not even speak English. Yet- they worked hard and made good lives for their families. Look how far we have come from that. What about your own Mom? Or Grandma, or Aunt, or Cousin etc. These are the people in my opinion who should be a young girl's role models. Not some person they read a book about. Your own family should be inspiring you to become all you dream of. YMMV.
I'm gonna have to go with Mulan, and Belle.....What??! OH! These are REAL people we're asking about?? sorry.....

In deedInteresting choice. She led a life of promiscuity, died broke, addicted to drugs and in legal problems.
A wonderful talent who led a pitiful life.
OMG, I didn't even have to click on the Samantha Smith link. I adored that girl. Had a book about her and everything. I was devastated when she died. There was only a few years difference between us and I thought she was so beautiful and so smart.

It totally depends on what's important to you. I wouldn't want my kids looking up to Gloria Steinem. I'd much rather they emulate someone like Sandra Bullock who can laugh at herself and show grace in a terrible situation then someone who supports and fights for things that I don't agree with.
Everyone's answer will be different, for different reasons. I also think that it's more important to talk about role models in general instead of separating them into male and female categories. Understanding why you respect someone is more important in my opinion than caring what their gender is.
I think every person has serious character flaws if you dig deep enough. That's a really important point. I think its necessary to show young girls great women in power but also point out where these women fail. Gloria Steinem has been very oppressive and openly transphobic in the past. But she is also a major fighter for reproductive freedom. Her failure in one realm doesn't undermine her victories in another. It shows that she's a human and you shouldn't try to be her, you should be yourself but know that you can accomplish great things because of the women who came before you and paved the roads.
And Mother Theresa wasn't the saint we all thought she was, which came out after her death. Apparently she was having a huge crisis of faith and wanted no part of any of it when she died.
As for Princess Di and JKO, they were able to maintain their dignity in the face of much adversity and maintain their composure during the most trying times. I also think they were wonderful mothers and since everyone else is saying "mom" why don't they count?![]()