Oh, OK - I thought it must be for 2007!!! BUT, I wish those rates would hurry up!!!!! I'm ready to book - LOL
I"m not sure why her price was more? Is she adding a TA fee? or Taxes? I really don't know.
Anyway - What you would need to do to determine if a package is right for you is to add each component of your trip - including your meals, and see which way is cheaper. I know that with a package you are paying RACK RATE for your room - NO discount, you are paying FULL price for your tickets and you pay for the dining plan. For us, especially if we get a discount code it makes the most sense. Here is the reason why - my DH is a big eater, we like to have at least one sit down meal a day, we like to do the character meals and we like to do signature dining........ if your family doesn't then a package may not be right for you. ** Plus, you are right, you do get added things with a package, that you would not get doing each thing seperately. We added up each component, plus food - both ways- on the dining plan and not on. On our last trip we saved over $400 - that was on FOOD alone, plus we got the park hoppers free - which saved $, and there was a slight discount on the room - disney refunded me the difference so we added 2 more nights to our trip.
Here is an example of ONE day on the dining plan, and one day NOT on it
-- remember in this comparison you are paying FULL price for your room/tickets/dining.
This is for 2 adults - 1 child. The price INCLUDES tax for room/tickets.
This is LOOSELY based on individual component Aug. 2007 prices since I don't know the actual package rates - also, 2008 rates will probably be more.
2 Adult - 1 day park hopper tickets - $238.58
($71.36 each+ $47.93 per hopper)
1 Child - 1 day park hopper ticket - $112.89
Total for Tickets = $351.47
1 Night Room Only Resv. @ WL - $241.88
Meals for the day -
Breakfast @ Roaring forks -
2 Adult B-fast platters - $5.99 each (tax NOT included) = $11.98
2 drinks - coffee/water = $1.99 + $2.00 = $3.99
1 Child B-fast platter - $3.99 + 1 milk $1.29 = $5.28
Total for B-fast = $21.25 - excluding tax
Lunch @ Cosmic Rays
1 Adult rib/chick. combo - $13.99
1 Adult BBQ meal - $8.99
1 Child nuggets - $3.99 (drink included)
2 drinks - $4.78
Total for lunch = $31.75 - excluding tax
Dinner @ Chef Mickey's
2 Adults $27.99 each - $55.98
1 child $12.99
Total = $68.97 - excluding tax
TOTAL for one days meals = $121.97 - excludes tax and tip
Total for 1 day trip = $715.32
SAME TRIP w/Dining Plan
2 Adult Dining Plans - $38.99 each
1 Child Dining Plan - $10.99
Total = $88.97
Tickets - $351.45
Room - $241.88
Dining Plan - $88.97 - for one days meals.
Total = $682.30 This also INCLUDES Tax & Tips! SO, you could potentially save over $32.00 that day alone.
*** Remember though - you'd have to utilize the dining plan the right way - meaning that if you don't want to have to pay out of pocket for b-fast for example, you can use your snack credits for b-fast items under $4.00, otherwise depending on where you dine it could cost more.
You really need to just add up your trip doing it both ways and see which one makes more sense for your family. Again, we like the dining plan and will get it, it works out great for us!
I hope this helps - but again, it all varies on how you would use the dining plan, if any discounts come out, etc...... I'm basing everything on full pricing for each component and utilizing the dining plan in a way where I'm not paying OOP for my 3 meals.