I have made bags of the goodies, so I can give them out all at once...It just takes too long otherwise! I really don't have a preference when to give them out, but I would say dont wait until the last night because then the kids wont have much time to enjoy...and your bags have to be packed and outside your door by 11pm...So I would say delivery them on day 1 and 2..and the 3rd night don't...also most people pull magnets and fish extenders off the doors at that point also!
I agree with the plan but then also agree with Tinks - there are quite a few of us trading gifts and as long as some of us do it the first night the kids should be cool!!! Having to take down by 11pm on the last night kinda of puts a stop to that one.
So how about we will do our 'gift giving' on the first night to help start that one off . . .