Fat Girls

Minerva Mouse

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
1,711
The dinner bill for three friends at Chilly D's Restaurant stung, but it wasn't the price - printed on the top of the receipt were the words "Fat Girls".

"I got the bill, I was looking at bill [and] I was like, 'Why does this receipt say 'fat girls?'" customer Christine Duran said.

The friends had dined out at the Stockton, Calif., restaurant, which is a part of the Cameo Casino Restaurant, on Thursday. The bill lists charges for three tri-tips with fries and three sodas, for a total of $25.50. A bartender named Jeff had apparently typed in "Fat Girls" to keep track of their bill.

When Duran asked a manager for an explanation, he "had like a smirk on his face, like it was funny but trying not to laugh," she said.

The dining experience went from bad to worse when the restaurant demanded they still pay the bill, offering them a 25 percent discount and then a 50 percent discount. They declined both offers.

In a Facebook message overnight, Maggie Lewis, the Cameo Club Casino owner, apologized and said the insulting treatment Duran and her friends had received is "intolerable in our establishment."

Jimmy Siemers, co-owner of Chilly D's, didn't work the night Duran and her friends received the offensive receipt, but he said he is trying to clean up the mess.

"I just want to tell them we're sincerely sorry and we'll do everything in our power to make sure this never happens to anyone again," he said.

It's certainly not the first time customers have been insulted on receipts.

In January, a Papa John's employee was fired after writing "Lady Chinky Eyes" on a receipt to identify an Asian customer.

A Maryland woman was insulted at a RadioShack in March when she purchased a cassette tape adapter and left with a receipt that read "ugly itch" from "tattoville," referring to the tattoos on her arm in memory of a child lost to SIDS and her deceased mother.

"Based on descriptions we've seen in the media, this incident obviously does not meet RadioShack's expectations for customer service," Eric Bruner, a spokesman for RadioShack told ABC News. "RadioShack responded immediately after seeing reports in the media, taking the strongest possible disciplinary actions." It is against company policy to discuss individual personnel matters but the company has taken the "strongest action available" in response to the issue, the spokesman said.

http://gma.yahoo.com/blogs/abc-blog...rant-bill-165554715--abc-news-topstories.html
 
I don't think I've ever looked at the top of a receipt before, but you can darn sure bet I'm gonna start.

:eek: Completely inappropriate!
 
The dinner bill for three friends at Chilly D's Restaurant stung, but it wasn't the price - printed on the top of the receipt were the words "Fat Girls".

"I got the bill, I was looking at bill [and] I was like, 'Why does this receipt say 'fat girls?'" customer Christine Duran said.

The friends had dined out at the Stockton, Calif., restaurant, which is a part of the Cameo Casino Restaurant, on Thursday. The bill lists charges for three tri-tips with fries and three sodas, for a total of $25.50. A bartender named Jeff had apparently typed in "Fat Girls" to keep track of their bill.

When Duran asked a manager for an explanation, he "had like a smirk on his face, like it was funny but trying not to laugh," she said.

Plus-Sized College Student Claims Discrimination at Bar

The dining experience went from bad to worse when the restaurant demanded they still pay the bill, offering them a 25 percent discount and then a 50 percent discount. They declined both offers.

In a Facebook message overnight, Maggie Lewis, the Cameo Club Casino owner, apologized and said the insulting treatment Duran and her friends had received is "intolerable in our establishment."

Jimmy Siemers, co-owner of Chilly D's, didn't work the night Duran and her friends received the offensive receipt, but he said he is trying to clean up the mess.

"I just want to tell them we're sincerely sorry and we'll do everything in our power to make sure this never happens to anyone again," he said.

It's certainly not the first time customers have been insulted on receipts.


http://gma.yahoo.com/blogs/abc-blog...rant-bill-165554715--abc-news-topstories.html

What about that is discrimination?
 
What about that is discrimination?

I agree its in very poor taste and as another "fat girl" it would make me mad and I would be speaking to a manager... but to be discrimination wouldn't you have to be treated differently?

If the bill was right and they didnt know anything was wrong until they got the bill I don't see how you can claim discrimination.

The restaurant is still wrong though... I have to wonder why they even let employees type things in to identify tables. Wouldn't it be easier to just have table numbers and print them at the top of the receipt? No one can really complain about being labeled table 32.
 

That was a link to another article, I should have removed it before I copied and pasted, sorry. It has since been removed.

I didn't click the link, I thought that was part of the story. Why do they put links like that in the middle of an article anyway :confused3
No need to apologize but thanks for explaining :)
 
The dinner bill for three friends at Chilly D's Restaurant stung, but it wasn't the price - printed on the top of the receipt were the words "Fat Girls".

"I got the bill, I was looking at bill [and] I was like, 'Why does this receipt say 'fat girls?'" customer Christine Duran said.

The friends had dined out at the Stockton, Calif., restaurant, which is a part of the Cameo Casino Restaurant, on Thursday. The bill lists charges for three tri-tips with fries and three sodas, for a total of $25.50. A bartender named Jeff had apparently typed in "Fat Girls" to keep track of their bill.

When Duran asked a manager for an explanation, he "had like a smirk on his face, like it was funny but trying not to laugh," she said.

The dining experience went from bad to worse when the restaurant demanded they still pay the bill, offering them a 25 percent discount and then a 50 percent discount. They declined both offers.

In a Facebook message overnight, Maggie Lewis, the Cameo Club Casino owner, apologized and said the insulting treatment Duran and her friends had received is "intolerable in our establishment."

Jimmy Siemers, co-owner of Chilly D's, didn't work the night Duran and her friends received the offensive receipt, but he said he is trying to clean up the mess.

"I just want to tell them we're sincerely sorry and we'll do everything in our power to make sure this never happens to anyone again," he said.

It's certainly not the first time customers have been insulted on receipts.

In January, a Papa John's employee was fired after writing "Lady Chinky Eyes" on a receipt to identify an Asian customer.

A Maryland woman was insulted at a RadioShack in March when she purchased a cassette tape adapter and left with a receipt that read "ugly itch" from "tattoville," referring to the tattoos on her arm in memory of a child lost to SIDS and her deceased mother.

"Based on descriptions we've seen in the media, this incident obviously does not meet RadioShack's expectations for customer service," Eric Bruner, a spokesman for RadioShack told ABC News. "RadioShack responded immediately after seeing reports in the media, taking the strongest possible disciplinary actions." It is against company policy to discuss individual personnel matters but the company has taken the "strongest action available" in response to the issue, the spokesman said.

http://gma.yahoo.com/blogs/abc-blog...rant-bill-165554715--abc-news-topstories.html
re: the bolded... yea, my dining experience always gets bad when a restaurant wants me to pay my bill.:rolleyes: Yes, the bartender did not act professionally. I don't think that entitles them to a discounted, much less free, meal.
 
I do not believe this was polite or the way we should treat people. However, I am not aware of any state where "weight" is a protected class...i.e., there is no legal right to be free of discrimination based on what you weigh. If there is a documented MEDICAL condition that causes weight gain, then perhaps one could make a case for discrimination based on disability.

It angers me when people toss around the word "discrimination" in such a cavalier fashion. In the vast majority of cases, one's weight is within one's control (much as hair style and hair color are). If someone wants to not hire someone with tats and pink hair, no one would be screaming "discrimination!"

As I said before though, the behavior in the OP was rude and unnecessary. Rude behavior happens all the time. It's not right, but it does.
 
I agree its in very poor taste and as another "fat girl" it would make me mad and I would be speaking to a manager... but to be discrimination wouldn't you have to be treated differently?

If the bill was right and they didnt know anything was wrong until they got the bill I don't see how you can claim discrimination.

The restaurant is still wrong though... I have to wonder why they even let employees type things in to identify tables. Wouldn't it be easier to just have table numbers and print them at the top of the receipt? No one can really complain about being labeled table 32.

:thumbsup2

Manager isn't the brightest bulb either IMO. $25.50 and now the owners have a boat load of bad publicity gaining like wild fire. :scared: Stupid!!

when your a owner of an eatery, the last thing you want is a rumor going around that you are running a joint with poor service and idiotic servers.
Now the owners are trying to put out PR fires (it's making the morning show rounds and it's on yahoo).
Manager should have been sucking up to those patrons and ensuring them that this type of thing would never happen again.
 
re: the bolded... yea, my dining experience always gets bad when a restaurant wants me to pay my bill.:rolleyes: Yes, the bartender did not act professionally. I don't think that entitles them to a discounted, much less free, meal.

Exactly. The bartender was in the wrong but refusing to pay when offered 50% off is ridiculous.
 
It didn't say the women refused to pay. It said they declined the offers of a discount.

As for being entitled to a free meal, not necessarily. But if that restaurant wanted to not only retain them as future customers AND prevent the firestorm of bad PR that can easily ruin a restaurant, they SHOULD have offered to comp the meal.
 
Do you make the customers happy, or do you run the risk of them posting to all the restaurant and shopping websites (Urbanspoon, Yelp etc.), posting the encounter on Facebook and talking about the encounter to every single person they meet? And, apparently, do you run the risk of the whole thing going viral?

Not the brightest move on the restaurant manager's part, even if it hadn't gone viral.:sad2:
 
It didn't say the women refused to pay. It said they declined the offers of a discount.

As for being entitled to a free meal, not necessarily. But if that restaurant wanted to not only retain them as future customers AND prevent the firestorm of bad PR that can easily ruin a restaurant, they SHOULD have offered to comp the meal.

I agree here.
 
Do you make the customers happy, or do you run the risk of them posting to all the restaurant and shopping websites (Urbanspoon, Yelp etc.), posting the encounter on Facebook and talking about the encounter to every single person they meet? And, apparently, do you run the risk of the whole thing going viral?

Not the brightest move on the restaurant manager's part, even if it hadn't gone viral.:sad2:

I think in this situation, even to be compensated the entire meal would have resulted in a bad review somewhere. A personal insult like that stings, and $$ doesn't take it away (at least not $25.50).

Although I did see a news article recently where an owner of a business was suing for a bad review on Angie's List. No one wins.
 
Ok may not be discrimination but definetly a very derogatory term. Think if they substituted a racial or ethnic slur, still not discrimantory but just as insulting.

I would avoid the place.
 
It didn't say the women refused to pay. It said they declined the offers of a discount.
It said their experience got worse when the restaurant demanded they pay the bill. Apparently the discounts offered weren't good enough. I'd say yes, they did refuse to pay.

As for being entitled to a free meal, not necessarily. But if that restaurant wanted to not only retain them as future customers AND prevent the firestorm of bad PR that can easily ruin a restaurant, they SHOULD have offered to comp the meal.
I agree the manager could have comped the meal. My point is the customers shouldn't have EXPECTED the meal to be comped.

If the bartender was quick on his feet, he'd say 'FAT' was his shorthand for 'Friendly, Attractive, Talkative'. :rotfl:
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom