The actual price of the Fantasmic dinner package is simply what you usually pay for the meal at H&V, Brown Derby or Mama Melrose (the three choices). It assures you a seat at Fantasmic without having to wait in line. Thus it is worth doing unless there are two Fantasmics the night you go and you are going to second one (which never fills and you can walk in very shortly before show starts through regular entry). Not sure what you saw about H&V. Personally consider it a very good buffet meal, mainly American faire--meats, fish, potatoes, veges etc. for which it is hard to screw up --and have always been treated fine by CM's there.