For those who have stayed at the BC and GF Sugarloaf CL - how would you compare the CR Atrium club? How does CR compare?
We've done all three.
All of the lounges can get busy at peak times, especially if all the CL rooms are full. Then again, that's not all bad either. Yes, there can be some challenge keeping food on the line, but the opposite is CL staff throwing food away, or food that sits out too long.
Among the lounges that were the worst in that regard- our recent AKL stay. I love BC, but I'd also say BC and YC can get pretty full, where you can't find a seat full.
The good news is that CR is one of our favorite CL's - and this is one of the aspects I enjoy. Then again...6:45am and 10pm are among my two favorite times to be in the lounge! At 6:45am, I can sip coffee and enjoy the view almost to myself as MK comes alive! At the other end, Wishes is at 10pm many parts of the year. As soon as the show is over, the lounge is empty. In the hubbub of WDw, it is relaxing to have a nice space like that to yourself.
If you really want low crowds, try to book the upper 14th floor lounge. The floor is mostly suites, so fewer guests. When we stayed there, the only way to get that floor was to call WDW. (that might have changed.)
The biggest plus of CR though is how quickly you can get around the resort, to GF/Poly via monorail, and to MK via walking. The downside is being far from the World Showcase, and the minimal theming of CR. If we stay at CR, we find our best ADR options were always at CR/GF/Poly/WL (Ft. WL is also fine). The boat to WL isn't super fast, but it is relaxing and peaceful.