Well, I think the new Reunion Resort is going to be the nicest- but the price tag and limited rentals are going to reflect that too. I don't think Emerald Island is the nicest-- but it ranks right up there w/ quite a few others. It seems that many of the developmental resorts in the general vicinity have similar amenities and are all great places. I'd check out not only Emerald Island, but also Formosa Gardens, and Windsor Hills too.