Hi Mike,
We too obessed about which night to miss. 1st cruise we missed 2nd night at Animator's completely. 2nd cruise, we accompanied the kids to dinner at Animator's and then went dinner at Palo. We had 2nd seating so, dinner that evening was pretty late, but oh so wonderful. The kiddos enjoy watching the old Disney cartoons. Our family enjoys LUM's & Parrot Cay more than Animator's Palate. Have light meals whatever night you decide to go to Palo's. Marco has been our server and he's quite the host!
Don't forget to make brunch ressies also.
Enjoy!
Pocono