I don't know what size room you are looking at, but I feel that the real beauty of
DVC can't be experienced in a studio. The studios are larger and better equipped than any others on property, but still, you really need to consider one bedroom and larger units.
I stay in the Grand Villas. I stay in the two lowest point seasons. With 430 points, I can stay 10-12 nights each year. This unit rents for somewhere in the range of $1,000 per night. My dues are less than $1500 per year. I think its pretty easy to see how much savings are involved.
As far as no daily maid service, I really see that as a plus. I really don't like the idea of someone in my room each and every day. You have a full laundry room and throwing a few towels in is pretty easy. We really never missed the housekeeping for a minute.
Even using you example, and I am not sure what size room you used, let's say you could rent that room for $200 per night, $1400 per week....plus room tax....somewhere around $800 per year savings....ok, not alot, but you would still recoup your investment in 15 years. If, If, If room rates don't go up.
If room rates don't go up.
If room rates don't go up.
That is a big part of this whole equation. Dues have lagged WAY, WAY behind room rates in increases. Room rates have seen 10% increases very often. In three years that $1400 room could be %1700 or more pretty easily. Now you yearly savings goes to $1100, chopped a few years off that payback period right there.
If you were looking at a low season one bedroom unit for 200 points, now you are looking at $300-400 per night, maybe $2500 per week.....plus 11% room tax that is costing you dues, so you annual savings is closer to $1700-1800, chopped a few more years off the breakeven.
Now we do the room increases again and we can see $3000+ cost pretty easily while you are still just paying dues that have lagged behind in increases.
It is actually a pretty easy equation, if you intend to go to Disney at least every other year and you don't mind staying in the finest resorts on WDW property, DVC is probably a good idea.