I never really understood the hype either. I have always loved the way they look on the outside, though. But the rooms and lobby always seemed "meh" for me. I think it's the color scheme that always put me off, for some reason. And it just felt like faux-fancy or something. I can't quite explain it.
That said, I do like the
DVC villas the more I look at them. And we might try to stay there someday. I think I'm just more of a darker color scheme with a rustic vibe type of person.
We have been happy with our 6 nights (5 park days) at
Disneyland these last couple trips. But we are actually considering adding a 7th night in the future (but not an extra park day.) I feel like we rarely spend much time at the pool or wandering DTD. Plus, we never really venture off site at all. As we start to travel to DLR once a year or so now...I'm hoping to maybe take some more time away from the parks just to visit some places in the area. I just need to convince my husband since he never really wants to leave the grounds.
For WDW, 7 nights seems to be a good amount for us. It's just a crazy amount of walking and so much time spent getting on and off buses that by the end of the week, we've had our fill.