hey when you use distressed furniture - you have got to expect this type of thing. the furniture looks old - so what if it damaged more.
DVC did NOT think this through - my opinion.
when I went through the tour, the guide was quick to point out the distressed areas and say it was planned that way. So no one would complaint about old the furniture looked.
Part of the problems with BCV is either the members who brought here didn't understand the plan or were not told by their guides.
It received complaints in that first year. much, much too soon for the wear and tear you are refering to - to have happened.
Now if if the furniture has gone down that far - then yes they might have a problem. but kept in mind when you age furniture each and every piece will be a little different.
what you are calling in bad shape - might actually be what was done to it originally.
Besides my best argument is that Disney hasn't as of yet replaced it. If it was as worn out as you and others say. Disney would have replaced as well as sue the manufacture for giving them defective furniture. they have not done either.
This is DVC most popular resort. Don't you think they want it to look excellent.
they should have done what they did for OKW - tell the story for the first few years. I think that would have caused far less complaints.
Now I would not be surprise if this latest rehab is to replace the furniture - but since furniture generally has a lifetime of what 10 years - don't count on it.
I haven't been recently - maybe a returned trip is needed. but when I was there that first month - the furniture was definitely worn - it has been slammed by a hammer. but since the paint (or whatever it was) was not hurt - it done that way intentional.
next visit look at the paint - if it is still on - then guess what - it is what Disney wanted.
in my experience you can't ban something with hammer or other things and expect the paint to be still on. okay this may not be paint - but some stain - that may not act like paint.
but hey do it - since the furniture is so bad off and no one could tell anyway.