I too infrequently use the pools on any of the ships I've cruised on. I spend my time swimming on the beaches or doing water sports at the ports and use the ship time for other things.
That said, I totally understand and appreciate the concern regarding whether there will be enough pool space. Personally, I think once the cruises get underway, only then will we know if it is anything of major issue. With as beautiful as this ship looks, a smaller pool area certainly is not keeping me away from booking on her.
Like almost everyone else, I have not seen the pools myself, but I don't think they are as small as everyone thinks. Plus, even assuming every bed is filled, not all 4000 passengers are going to want to swim at the same time. The family pool looks 100X more inviting to me than the hole in the ground that is the Goofy pool. The Donald pool also looks larger to me than the Goofy pools, especially when you consider its shape and the fact that the ship itself is much wider. There are a few pics thus far with people next to it, but when I look at pics of the Magic, the Donald pool certainly looks bigger to me. 40% bigger? Probably not, but with everything else to do and all the deck space, it may work.
Plus, if they can hold 12 people in the Magic's Elevators (if I'm remembering right), that pool can hold more than 25
