I'm worried that BC won't live up to the YC too. I

the YC.
If a great AP rate comes along for early August, I may just book the two rooms at YC. The only advantage of BCV is the shorter walk to Epcot with my 2 nephews in the blazing August heat.
True but then again, the YC is a closer walk to the boardwalk bakery and DHS!
We have never stayed at the WL. When it comes up as a possiblity for a family trip, we end up booking a different resort. There are just so many options at WDW. I'd like to try all of the deluxe resorts eventually. BWI, GF, WL, and AKL are left.
WL is great and the boat to MK? Priceless. Not to mention relatively easy access to all the MK resort dining options.

I'll admit, I actually liked our view better at WL believe it or not even though the balcony itself was smaller. I'd stay there again, I think our biggest issue was the bedding, it just paled in comparison to the comfort of the YC bedding. Plus the YC room was quite a bit larger (as it should be for the cost jump!) But, at the end of the day at our kids ages and for us...the ability to walk to Epcot just beats out the boat to the MK. If you had younger kids, I don't know which would win!
Did you book your crusie through Disney directly? Or did you use a
travel agent?
I used my TA. Which is kind of funny after my whining about her but the best way to get OBC is through a TA and I was able to do a little shopping around for the deals that were out there and she matched that as best she could so I ended up with 3 OBC's, one via Disney Direct for $25, one by using our Disney Visa for $50 and then she's matching the
Dreams Unlimited OBC offer, which for our class was $200, so $275 total. I could have gotten slightly more if I booked through magic for less but feel much better about using someone I know who responds quickly. The big ones (DU and MFL) take a good 2 days to respond and that doesn't work for me.
So, souvie money is covered!

All I could have gotten on my own by booking direct (sans a PIN which is unlikely for that time and location) was $75.
Disney does do some great off season offers, kids cruise free is the best, but of course it doesn't work with our timeline. And, as I understand it, if you do basically a bounceback and book another one while onboard, those incentives are really nice, 10% off and I think a $200 OBC plus only 10% down instead of 20%.
Okay, somehow, I missed the YC check in update! Now that I've gone back, I am understanding the conversation much better!!
It is a beautiful room! Very classy that YC! You lucked out with an awesome CM there!
How exciting for the Alaska cruise too! It's on my bucket list! Don't know when, but we will do it. We want the girls to set foot in all 50 states, so that's the best way to get Alaska in my mind! We have most of the western have of the US to go yet. It helps that we drive to FL a lot, so we can get the eastern half done on road trips!
Anyway, back to business. WHAT HAPPENED??? Did you make all your scheduled appearances or not???? I'm betting on you did!
We DID luck out on the room and check in and it helped in ways we couldn't have possibly known at the time. Ridiculously complicated and stressful for what should be a basic check in and all self inflicted but blessedly, it worked out!
50 states, that's a great goal, I'd love to do that but I have the reverse issue, most of the southern and some of the eastern.