1.) fish extender goodies are totally optional...not everyone has the time, patience, or money to do it...and that's fine! The cruise itself and all the awesome friends you meet onboard are gift enough....everthing else is just gravy!
2.) Our favorite fish extender goodies were things that were edible and/or small....remember that anything you put in there has to go home with the person-----so a magnet or a baggy of candy or a cute Mickey pen are good options.....a new set of golf clubs, as lovely a gesture as they might be, are probably not good fish extender fare!!
3.) Fish extender goodies should be inexpensive.....it's the gesture that counts.....save your money for excursions and spa treatments!!!
4.) As Deanna pointed out....fish extender gifts should be fun...not stress you out! We also saw more than one DISer on our last trip for whom giving out the goodies became the most harrowing and stressful part of their day!

Trust me----if passing out baggies of candy to all of us fellow DISers is going to ruin an otherwise MAGICal day for you....none of us want that....go to the Rainforest Room or the Pool or get yourself a DOD instead!!