Hey all,
I've been procrastinating my desire to post this question/thought because I thought the answer might reveal itself over time..but as we get deeper into discussions of secret mickeys (or since we're at sea maybe Secret Ariels? or Nemos? or Flounders? or Pirates?) and fish extenders....it seems a good time to ask the question.
So what exactly does it mean to sign up for "fish extender fun"? On my last cruise where we did fish extenders...it really wasn't that formal...we didn't actually sign up for anything. People who WANTED to bring little gifts just brought enough for everyone on the DIS thread and then went around and put them in people's fish extenders (if they had one...if they didn't they'd often leave them hanging on the doorknob or even ask the housekeeping staff to put it in the room for them). Our group ALSO did a secret mickey which was much more formal. People who wanted to do it signed up and the names got shuffled around by someone who was the coordinator and each participant was assigned a cruiser or cabin (some people did it individually and others as couples) then set a price limit, etc. So here is my question:
1.) Is the list of people signing up for "fish extender fun" with Kimberly people who are just letting her know that we intend to have a fish extender on our door so people know how many gifts to bring if they want to bring little goodies?.....or....
2.) Are these people who sign up committing themselves to not only receive but to also GIVE fish extender gifts?
Also, if it's the former then I wonder do we really need a closed group on the other website? (which I must confess I signed up for but haven't looked at in months....I barely have time to read this thread much less a whole other website with its own sign ups and posts and discussion threads and such!

.....although I definitely appreciate all the hard work that obviously went into that site!).
Also, if we do end up creating a secret mickey event for this cruise, then Jason and I would happily join that fun (as a couple/cabin)!